Authority: High Court of Judicature at Madras

Order Date: 18-11-2026

Case Overview

  • Parties: Marine Electricals (India) Limited (Petitioner) vs. NLC India Limited (Respondent).
  • Nature of Proceeding: Writ Petition under Article 226 seeking certiorari and mandamus to obtain records of the impugned order dated 11.11.2025 and to compel release of the outstanding 5% retention money with interest.
  • Contract Background: NLCIL invited bids for a 15 MW (AC) grid‑interactive solar power plant at Ettankulam Village, Tamil Nadu. Marine Electricals was awarded the contract by letter dated 28.02.2017; contract executed on 08.06.2017.
  • Project Milestones:
  • Provisional Acceptance Certificate (grid connectivity) issued on 04.03.2019.
  • Commissioning completed on 28.04.2021.
  • Petitioner's request to commence Performance Guarantee (PG) test dated 16.06.2021; consent received on 30.06.2021; PG test commenced on 01.07.2021 (within 63 days of commissioning).
  • Final Acceptance Certificate issued by NLCIL on 19.07.2025, marking contractual closure.
  • Retention Money: Under Clauses 6.7.4, 6.9.3 and 6.10.3, 5 % of the contract value is retained and becomes payable upon successful PG test and issuance of the Final Acceptance Certificate. Conditions were satisfied as of 19.07.2025.
  • Dispute: NLCIL, in a communication dated 04.11.2025, indicated the retention was being processed but later issued an impugned order on 11.11.2025 invoking Clause 10.22.2.8 to levy liquidated damages and proposing set‑off of the retention, also threatening to encash the performance bank guarantee.
  • Respondent’s Contentions: Alleged delays in operation, shortfall in targets, and breach of timelines, invoking Clause 10.44.2 to argue that disputes must be resolved via arbitration, rendering the writ petition non‑maintainable.
  • Petitioner’s Contentions: No fault during project execution; NLCIL’s sudden hostility after follow‑up on retention is arbitrary. Relied on several Supreme Court precedents to justify court interference.
  • Court’s Interim Direction: Parties were invited to attempt amicable settlement; orders were reserved on 28‑09‑2026 and again on 18‑11‑2026.
  • Joint Memo: On 30 Oct 2026, both parties submitted a joint memo consenting to the appointment of Hon’ble Mr. Justice E. Padmanabhan (Retd) as sole arbitrator, subject to refund of the retention amount. The memo was recorded by the Court.
  • Bank Guarantees: Both parties agreed that the performance bank guarantees submitted by the petitioner will remain alive pending arbitration.

Final Outcome

1. The joint memo is recorded; Hon’ble Mr. Justice E. Padmanabhan (Retd) is appointed as the sole arbitrator to adjudicate the disputes.

2. The arbitrator shall enter the reference and decide the disputes; fees shall be as per Schedule IV of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996, borne equally by the parties.

3. The entire 5 % retention amount due to Marine Electricals shall be refunded within four weeks from the date the website‑uploaded copy of this order is available.

4. The petitioner shall keep the bank guarantees alive until the arbitration proceedings are disposed of.

5. All connected miscellaneous petitions are hereby closed.

Topics: Legal Dispute, Arbitration, Retention Money