Authority: High Court of Judicature at Bombay, Kolhapur Circuit Bench
Order Date: 16 November 2026
Case Overview
- Petitioners: former directors/chairmen of Solapur District Central Co-operative Bank Ltd., including Sanjay Vitthalrao Shinde (WP‑5976/2026), Ranjitsinh Vijaysinh Mohite‑Patil (WP‑5971/2026, WP‑5972/2026, WP‑5975/2026), Dilip Brahmadev Mane (WP‑5973/2026), Suresh Siddappa Hassapure (WP‑5974/2026) and numerous others listed in petitions 5971‑5979.
- Respondents: (1) Divisional Joint Registrar, Co‑operative Societies, Pune Division; (2) Returning Officer, Election to the Board of Directors of the Bank; (3) Solapur District Central Co‑operative Bank Ltd.; (4) State Co‑operative Election Authority, Maharashtra; (5) State of Maharashtra, Principal Secretary, Co‑operation, Marketing and Textile Department.
- Issue: Rejection of nomination forms for the 2026‑31 Board of Directors election by the Returning Officer on 3 November 2026, on grounds of disqualification under Section 73CA of the Maharashtra Co‑operative Societies Act, 1960 (MCS Act), based on a finding under Section 88 that petitioners were responsible for conduct detrimental to depositors and on the supersession order dated 28 May 2018 under Section 110‑A.
- Procedural History: Petitioners appealed the rejection before the Divisional Joint Registrar; the Registrar dismissed the appeal on 6 November 2026, confirming the Returning Officer’s order. The petitioners then filed separate writ petitions (WP‑5971 to WP‑5979, 2026) before this Court.
- Petitioners’ Arguments: They claimed resignation on 15 May 2018 before the enquiry concluded, argued that the appellate authority had failed to decide the appeal within the time‑frame ordered by this Court in WP‑2347/2025, and contended that the pendency of the appeal should stay the effect of the disqualification.
- Respondents’ Arguments: The disqualification was valid under Sections 73CA(1)(f)(iii) and 73CA(3A) of the MCS Act; pendency of the appeal does not remove the bar; an election petition under Section 77A is the appropriate remedy.
- Court’s Reasoning: The Court noted that petitioners were members of the Board from 2009 to 2018, that the preliminary enquiry under Section 83 began on 3 February 2018, that the enquiry under Section 88 was initiated in April 2018, and that the Commissioner’s supersession order of 28 May 2018 remains under appeal with no stay granted. Resignation prior to the conclusion of the enquiry does not negate the responsibility finding. Accordingly, Sections 73CA(1)(f)(iii) and 73CA(3A) disqualify persons held responsible under Section 88 or superseded under Section 110‑A, irrespective of a pending appeal. The Court found the petitioners’ reliance on earlier Supreme Court judgments inapplicable to the present facts.
- Outcome: All writ petitions (WP‑5971 to WP‑5979, 2026) are dismissed; the rejection of the petitioners’ nomination forms stands; no order as to costs.
Final Outcome
All writ petitions are dismissed, confirming the disqualification of the petitioners from the Solapur District Central Co‑operative Bank Ltd. board election.
Topics: Co‑operative Bank Election, Disqualification under MCS Act, High Court Judgment