Case Details
Case Name: CA (CAA) No.8/ALD/2026 (First Motion) - Scheme of Amalgamation of Pandey Leasing Private Limited, Varuna Biocell Private Limited, Varuna Herbo Biotec Private Limited with Swastik Formulations Private Limited
Court/Authority: National Company Law Tribunal, Allahabad Bench, Prayagraj
Case Number: CA(CAA) No. 08/ALD/2026
Order Date: 20.05.2026
Appointed Date of Scheme: 01.04.2025
Parties Involved
Transferor Companies:
- Pandey Leasing Private Limited (CIN: U65921UP1991PTC013295, PAN: AABCP3407C) - Engaged in leasing of movable and immovable properties
- Varuna Biocell Private Limited (CIN: U24231UP1999PTC024554, PAN: AABCV7390J) - Engaged in biotechnological and microbiological products
- Varuna Herbo Biotec Private Limited (CIN: U24221UP1989PTC011206, PAN: AAECA4180C) - Engaged in biotechnology, genetic engineering, and agricultural biotechnology
Transferee Company:
- Swastik Formulations Private Limited (CIN: U24231UP1989PTC010662, PAN: AADCS1920R) - Engaged in manufacturing medicines, drugs, and pharmaceutical preparations
Legal Representatives: Sh. Anurup Dutta along with Sh. Jnana Ranjan Dhal, Advocates
Tribunal Members: Mr. Praveen Gupta (Member-Judicial), Mr. Ashish Verma (Member-Technical)
Issues / Allegations / Violations
This is a first motion application under Sections 230 & 232 of the Companies Act, 2013 read with Rule 3 of Companies (Compromises, Arrangements and Amalgamations) Rules, 2016. The application seeks approval for the Scheme of Amalgamation whereby three transferor companies will amalgamate into Swastik Formulations Private Limited. The companies have confirmed that no investigation proceedings are pending against them under Sections 235-351 of Companies Act, 1956 or Sections 210-226 of Companies Act, 2013.
Findings & Observations
The Tribunal examined the written consents obtained from stakeholders:
Transferor Company No. 1 (Pandey Leasing):
- Equity Shareholders: 4 shareholders (100% consent by value of ₹1,04,000)
- Unsecured Creditors: 17 creditors (97.01% consent by value of ₹66,01,091)
- Secured Creditors: None
Transferor Company No. 2 (Varuna Biocell):
- Equity Shareholders: Details not provided in extract
- Unsecured Creditors: Details not provided in extract
- Secured Creditors: None
Transferor Company No. 3 (Varuna Herbo Biotec):
- Equity Shareholders: 5 shareholders (100% consent by value of ₹16,64,000)
- Unsecured Creditors: 1 creditor (100% consent by value of ₹1,70,231)
- Secured Creditors: None
Transferee Company (Swastik Formulations):
- Equity Shareholders: 5 shareholders (100% consent by value of ₹11,17,500)
- Unsecured Creditors: 106 creditors (94.08% consent by value of ₹3,38,55,754)
- Secured Creditors: None
The companies filed their latest audited financial statements as of 31.03.2025 and provisional financial statements as of 15.02.2026.
Penalties / Settlements / Directions
Share Exchange Ratio: Based on valuation report dated 17.02.2026 by CS Bidisha Achari (IBBI/RV/03/2022/15194):
- Transferor Company No. 1: 1 equity share of Transferee Company for every 2 equity shares held
- Transferor Company No. 2: 10 equity shares of Transferee Company for every 1 equity share held
- Transferor Company No. 3: 1 equity share of Transferee Company for every 7 equity shares held
Employee Protection: Clause 6 of the Scheme protects the interests of workmen and staff of all companies.
Corrective Actions & Future Obligations
The Tribunal directed that the Second Motion Petition must include notices to:
1. Central Government through Regional Director, Northern Region, MCA, New Delhi (rd.north@mca.gov.in)
2. Registrar of Companies, Uttar Pradesh, Kanpur (roc.kanpur@mca.gov.in)
3. Official Liquidator, Allahabad (ol.allahabad@mca.gov.in)
4. Jurisdictional Income Tax Department, Principal Chief Commissioner of Income Tax, Lucknow (lucknow.pccit@incometax.gov.in)
The Second Motion Petition must be filed within the prescribed time period under the Act and corresponding rules.
Final Ruling & Enforcement
The First Motion Application was allowed with the following directions:
- Meetings of equity shareholders of all companies are dispensed with due to 100% consent
- Meetings of unsecured creditors are dispensed with due to sufficient consent (94.08%-100% by value)
- No secured creditors exist in any company, so no meetings required
- Liberty granted to file Second Motion Petition with specific notice requirements
- Publication in newspapers to be addressed in second motion petition
The scheme aims to achieve better management control, simplify corporate structure, reduce compliance costs, eliminate duplication, achieve economies of scale, and allow management to focus on business growth.