Horace Mann reported Q1 2026 EPS $1.28 versus $1.13 forecast, a 13.3% surprise, and revenue $429.3M vs $319.5M forecast.
The company returned $33M to shareholders, including $18M share repurchases and a 3% dividend increase, its 18th consecutive year.
Property & casualty earnings rose 46% to $39M with combined ratio 83.3%, while group benefits sales tripled to $11M.
Despite strong results, the stock fell 1.78% in after‑hours trading, closing at $45.15, reflecting broader market conditions.