Authority: High Court of Jammu & Kashmir and Ladakh, Srinagar

Order Date: 17 November 2026

Case Overview

  • Parties: M/s Alpine Agro Services (appellant) vs Union of India and Food Corporation of India (respondents).
  • Background: FCI invited tenders under the Private Entrepreneur Guarantee (PEG) Scheme for construction of a 17,500 MT storage godown at Shilvat. Alpine Agro Services was awarded the contract; a Lease and Service Agreement was executed on 21 May 2013, deemed operative from 26 Feb 2015. The agreement required completion of drainage and black‑topping of the internal approach road, with an undertaking to finish by September 2015, later extended to 26 Feb 2016.
  • Delay: Black‑topping was finally completed in May‑June 2017. Respondents issued a penalty notice of ₹1,58,002 in 2018 and later additional recoveries via communications dated 03 Sep 2021 and 15 Nov 2021, invoking decisions of a High Level Committee (HLC) that altered hiring charges.
  • Lower Court: A Single Judge dismissed the writ petition on 06 June 2026, upholding the recoveries.
  • Appeal: Alpine Agro Services argued that the HLC decisions were extraneous to the lease, that penalties were arbitrary, not based on actual loss, and violated natural justice.

Final Outcome

  • The intra‑court appeal is allowed; the judgment of 06 June 2026 is set aside.
  • All recovery notices issued to Alpine Agro Services, including the ₹1,58,002 penalty, are quashed.
  • Respondents are directed to release any unpaid rentals due to Alpine Agro Services within two months of this order.
  • The court held that the HLC’s decisions could not unilaterally modify the lease agreement or impose penalties absent a contractual provision.

Topics: Contract Penalty, Court Judgment