Authority: High Court at Calcutta, Criminal Revisionary Jurisdiction
Order Date: 16.11.2026
Case Overview
- Parties: Petitioners – Amrit Cements Limited (a company under the Companies Act, 2013) and two of its office bearers; Opposite Party – Suraj Jha (complainant).
- Nature of Proceeding: Criminal revision application under Section 528 of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023 (equivalent to Section 482 Cr.P.C.) seeking quash of criminal case CS/55752/2024 filed under IPC Sections 420 (cheating), 406 (criminal breach of trust) and 120B (criminal conspiracy).
- Background: On 27 June 2023 Amrit Cements entered into a renovation contract with the opposite party for its head office at Trinity, 226/1, AJC Bose Road, Kolkata‑700020. The contract price was Rs 38,94,000. An advance of Rs 19,80,000 was paid in two tranches (27 June 2023 and 8 August 2023). The contractor was to complete the work within 45 days, provide a 12‑month warranty, and bear costs of any defects.
- Performance Issues: By 18 July 2023, less than 30 % of work was completed. Despite a notice on 19 July 2023 demanding increased manpower, the contractor failed to meet the deadline. The deadline was extended by an additional 30 days, yet no substantial progress occurred.
- Termination & Subsequent Costs: On 6 October 2023 the petitioners asked the contractor to vacate the premises. They later engaged another interior decorator at an additional cost of approximately Rs 30,00,000.
- Invoices & Payments: The contractor raised tax invoices of Rs 35,41,891 on 8 Oct 2023 and Rs 2,92,050 on 14 Nov 2023. Only the advance of Rs 19,80,000 had been paid; the final bill remained unpaid.
- Criminal Complaint: The opposite party filed a complaint on 26 April 2024 alleging cheating, criminal breach of trust and conspiracy, leading to the issuance of process and transfer of the case to the Metropolitan Magistrate, 10th Court, Calcutta. Summons were served on 29 July 2024.
- Petitioners’ Contentions: The petitioners argued that the dispute is purely civil, involving non‑payment of a contractual amount, and that there is no deception, entrustment or conspiracy as required under the cited IPC sections. They contended that the Trial Magistrate erred by issuing process without a Section 202 enquiry.
- Court’s Reasoning: The High Court observed that:
- Non‑payment of contractual dues does not constitute cheating under Section 420.
- No initial entrustment existed, so Section 406 is inapplicable.
- No agreement to commit an illegal act was made, rendering Section 120B inapplicable.
- The factual issues—completion of work, quality, and final bill settlement—are matters for a civil forum.
- The Trial Magistrate failed to conduct a proper enquiry under Section 202, leading to an abuse of process.
Final Outcome
- The revision application (CRR No. 3705 of 2024) is allowed.
- The criminal proceeding CS/55752/2024 under Sections 420, 406 and 120B of the IPC, pending before the Metropolitan Magistrate, 10th Court, Calcutta, is quashed as far as the petitioners are concerned.
- The orders dated 26 April 2024 and 26 June 2024 are set aside.
- Interim orders, if any, are vacated.
- The judgment is to be communicated to the lower court for information, and certified copies may be obtained upon compliance with legal formalities.
Topics: Court Proceedings, Civil‑Criminal Jurisdiction, Contract Dispute