Authority: High Court at Calcutta
Order Date: 16.11.2026
Case Overview
- Petitioners: Aditya Bahl and another director of Ava Spa Holidays Pvt Ltd (CRR 17 of 2023).
- Respondents: State of West Bengal and an opposite party (the complainant company).
- Underlying dispute: Four bilateral agreements between Ava Spa Holidays (acting as booking agent) and Private Charter Ltd (UAE) for chartered‑flight services to the opposite party, M/S Vesuvius India Ltd.
- Payments: ₹41,44,700 transferred by Vesuvius India to Ava Spa’s bank account between 27.07.2018 and 07.09.2018; an additional ₹6,07,700 paid on 21.09.2018, totalling ₹41,44,700.
- Contract dates: 12.09.2018 (two contracts), 11.08.2018, and 13.08.2018. The contracts contained a Force‑Majeure clause and stipulated Delhi jurisdiction.
- Alleged breach: The first scheduled flight on 26.09.2018 was cancelled; petitioners claimed bad weather, but RT‑I and airport records showed no adverse weather and no flight was ever booked.
- Criminal complaint: Filed on 11.03.2019 (Taratala Police Station Case No. 18 of 2019) alleging cheating and criminal breach of trust under IPC §§ 420/120B. A charge‑sheet was filed against the two directors, and the Additional Chief Judicial Magistrate (ACJM) at Alipore issued summons.
- Petitioners’ submissions: argued lack of vicarious liability, absence of the company as an accused, procedural defect in the magistrate’s cyclostyle order (violation of Rule 183), and that the dispute is purely contractual, warranting civil remedy. Cited Supreme Court precedents (Shailesh Kumar Singh vs State of UP, Sushil Sethi vs State of Arunachal Pradesh, Maksud Saeed vs State of Gujarat, Sunil Bharti Mittal vs CBI, etc.) rejecting vicarious liability absent specific statutory provision.
- Respondent State’s argument: asserted that investigation revealed intentional deception by the directors, that the amount was received, and that the directors induced the complainant to part with money.
- Opposite party’s argument: claimed no flight was ever scheduled, no adverse weather existed, and the directors failed to refund the advance despite the Force‑Majeure clause being misused.
- Court’s analysis: affirmed that directors cannot be held criminally liable when the company itself is not impleaded and no specific allegation of personal mens rea is made; highlighted the magistrate’s mechanical issuance of summons without judicial mind; reiterated Supreme Court rulings that vicarious liability under the IPC is not permissible unless expressly provided by statute; noted that the complaint essentially concerns non‑refund of advance payment, a civil breach of contract.
Final Outcome
- The High Court, exercising its inherent power under Section 482 CrPC, quashed the entire criminal proceeding against the petitioners.
- Order: The proceedings arising from Taratala Police Station Case No. 18 of 2019 under §§ 420/120B IPC are hereby quashed; no costs awarded; all connected applications stand disposed of.
Topics: Criminal Law, Corporate Liability, Contract Dispute