Authority: High Court of Judicature at Madras

Order Date: 20 November 2026

Case Overview

  • Parties: Appellant is M/s Azeez Badsha Sahib’s Charities, a religious public charitable institution, represented by its Secretary. Respondents are the legal heirs of the deceased defendants Mr. Nazeer Hussain and Ms. Ameena Bi, namely Humera Begum, Haleema Begum, Abdul Rahim Baig, Hasina Begum, Rahana Begum, Sabira Begum, A.R. Fazal Baig, Mateen Baig, Razina Sultana, Fahim Sultana, N. Hyder Hussain, N. Jameel Hussain, together with H.H. Prince of Arcot Endowments and P. Damodharan.
  • Original Suit: O.S. No.367 of 2008 filed in the I Assistant City Civil Court, Chennai, seeking vacant possession of a house and ground situated at Old No.316, New No.96, Big Mosque Compound, Triplicane, Chennai‑600 005 and damages of Rs 2000 per month from 1 June 2007 until delivery of possession.
  • Notice of Termination: Plaintiff issued notice (Ex.A1) dated 12 April 2007, received by defendants on 13 April 2007 and 17 April 2007, terminating the month‑to‑month tenancy effective 31 May 2007.
  • Tenancy Details: Original tenant was Mr. Abbas Hussain. After his death, defendants 1 and 2 (the heirs) continued as tenants, paying Rs 150 initially, then Rs 300, and finally Rs 2000 per month. Rent was payable on or before the 5th of each succeeding month.
  • Trial Court Findings (16 July 2014): Validity of termination notice upheld; defendants were held to be tenants in occupation; admission of Rs 2000 payment accepted; decree granted for possession within three months and damages at Rs 2000 per month, together with costs.
  • First Appellate Court (A.S. No.35 of 2015, 11 December 2015): Set aside the trial court judgment, holding that the plaintiff had not proved ownership of the land, that the unregistered lease (Ex.A5) could not be relied upon, and that the evidence of payment was insufficient.
  • Second Appeal (SA No.450 of 2016, filed 28 April 2016): Raised four substantial questions of law – (1) fatality of non‑examination of defendants, (2) failure to consider entire evidence, (3) application of Section 116 of the Indian Evidence Act, and (4) admissibility of Ex.A5 for collateral purpose.
  • Court’s Reasoning: The High Court held that defendants’ personal knowledge could not be proved through a power‑of‑attorney agent, creating an adverse inference; the first appellate court failed to analyse admissions and the lease document; Section 116 estops tenants from denying landlord’s title; Ex.A5, though unregistered, is admissible for collateral purpose under the proviso to Section 49 of the Registration Act; the lease is a month‑to‑month tenancy and therefore does not require registration under Section 17(1)(d) of the Registration Act.

Final Outcome

  • The High Court allowed the second appeal, set aside the 2015 appellate order and restored the 2014 trial court decree.
  • Defendants 5 to 16 are ordered to quit and deliver vacant possession of the suit schedule property within three months of receipt of the judgment copy.
  • Defendants must pay damages at Rs 2000 per month from 1 June 2007 until possession is delivered, with credit for any amounts already paid during that period.
  • The costs awarded by the trial court are also restored.

Topics: Property Dispute, Landlord‑Tenant Law