Authority: Calcutta High Court
Order Date: 19 November 2026
Case Overview
- Revision petition (CRR 3807 of 2024) filed by Abhijit Das & others (petitioner) against State of West Bengal & ANR, heard on 07‑09‑2026, judgment on 19‑11‑2026.
- Underlying criminal case G.R. No. 3142 of 2024 before Chief Judicial Magistrate, Barasat, arising from Rajarhat Police Station case No. 295 of 2024 dated 10‑08‑2024, invoking IPC sections 406, 419, 420, 465, 120B.
- Petitioners are residents of “The Soul” housing complex (550 flats, phases 1 & 2) constructed by P.S. Primarc Projects Private Limited. In July 2023 a 15‑member “Soul Cultural Committee” was formed to organise Durga Puja 2023 and other festivals; ₹2,500 subscription was collected from 318 (later cited as 378) flat owners; a bank account was opened in SBI Sukho Brishti Branch in the committee’s name.
- The committee obtained a “No Objection Certificate” from the developer on 16‑09‑2023 and successfully conducted Durga Puja 2023, Lakshmi Pooja, Kali Pooja, Diwali, Holi and an exhibition (20‑Sep to 24‑Dec 2023).
- Opposite Party No. 2, a resident and practising advocate, objected to a proposed Baishakhi Mela in the community hall and alleged that the committee illegally opened the bank account, impersonated the developer, collected funds from 550 flat owners and 200 phase‑2 allottee owners, siphoned money, and committed cheating, forgery and criminal conspiracy.
- Opposite Party No. 2 filed an application under Section 156(3) CrPC on 14‑05‑2024; the Chief Judicial Magistrate ordered registration of FIR on 08‑08‑2024; charge‑sheet later filed alleging offences under the aforementioned IPC sections.
- Petitioners moved this Court under Section 482 CrPC, contending the case is frivolous, vexatious, mala‑fide, and that no wrongful loss was suffered; they highlighted the NOC, audit report, lack of any seized documents, absence of developer’s statement, and that the committee’s tenure ended on 31‑03‑2024.
- The State argued that the charge‑sheet prima‑facie establishes the offences and that witnesses must be examined.
- The Court examined the material, noting:
- No documents were seized to prove forgery or siphoning of funds.
- The audit report showed only a minor unpaid voucher of ₹6,000 for a Lakshmi idol; no evidence of misappropriation.
- No statement from the developer or the appointed chartered accountant auditor was recorded.
- The complaint was lodged after the committee’s tenure had expired and after a personal grievance regarding the community hall.
- The charge‑sheet lacked specific evidence linking the petitioners to the alleged offences.
- Citing Supreme Court precedents (Mahmood Ali, Haji Iqbal, Ravindra Goenka, Rocky v Telangana, etc.), the Court reiterated that quashing under Section 482 is an extraordinary power, to be exercised only when the complaint is manifestly untenable or the proceeding is an abuse of process.
- The Court found that the allegations did not satisfy the essential ingredients of offences under Sections 406, 419, 420, 465, 120B IPC; the investigating officer had failed to collect material evidence; and proceeding would constitute an abuse of process.
Final Outcome
- The revision application is allowed. The criminal proceedings pending before the Chief Judicial Magistrate, Barasat, arising out of Rajarhat Police Station case No. 295 of 2024 under IPC sections 406, 419, 420, 465, 120B are quashed against the petitioners.
- All other connected applications, if any, are disposed of.
Topics: Legal Proceedings, Real Estate