Authority: High Court at Calcutta (Constitutional Writ Jurisdiction Appellate Side)

Order Date: 19 November 2026

Case Overview

  • Petitioners: Carbon Resources Private Limited & Anr.; Respondents: Steel Authority of India Limited (SAIL) and others, including Durgapur Steel Plant and the Union of India.
  • Tender: Durgapur Steel Plant issued a Government e‑Marketplace (GeM) tender for supply of Petroleum Coke (V2) to IS 8502(Q3) for a total quantity of 21,380,000 units.
  • The petitioners submitted Bank Guarantee No. 190BG09262810001 dated 8 Oct 2026 for Rs 70,15,000, addressed to “M/S Steel Authority of India Ltd, SAIL‑DSP, Chandrapur Ferro Alloy Plant…”.
  • On 28 Oct 2026 the petitioner discovered the address error and sent a letter to the bank; YES Bank issued an amendment letter correcting the beneficiary to “SAIL‑DSP, Durgapur Steel Plant, Durgapur‑713203, West Bengal”.
  • The Technical Evaluation Committee disqualified the petitioner on 12 Nov 2026, stating that the BG uploaded on GeM was in favour of SAIL‑CFAP and the corrected BG was submitted after the Time of Delivery (ToD) and not uploaded on GeM.
  • Petitioners sought a court direction to accept the amended BG and to allow participation in the reverse auction scheduled to close on 19 Nov 2026 03:00 PM.
  • Counsel for petitioners relied on Patna High Court judgment (Aarpee Infra Projects vs State of Bihar, 29 Mar 2019) and Supreme Court judgment (Poddar Steel Corp vs Ganesh Engineering Works, 1991 3 SCC 273) supporting acceptance of a BG with a clerical error.
  • Respondent counsel (Kishore Datta) argued that the tender expressly required the beneficiary to be “AGM, Durgapur Steel Plant (SAIL), Durgapur‑713203, West Bengal” and that Clause 4a of the tender document mandates rejection if EMD documents are not in order.
  • The counsel also cited Supreme Court judgments (Vidarbha Irrigation Development Corp vs An​oj Kumar Garwala, 23 Jan 2019; Monarch Infrastructure vs Ulhasnagar Municipal Corp, 2000 5 SCC 287; Central Coalfields Ltd vs SLL‑SML Joint Venture, 2016 8 SCC 622) emphasizing material deviation and strict compliance with tender terms.

Final Outcome

  • The Court held that the address mismatch constituted a material deviation and that the tender terms required the EMD to be in the exact name of the beneficiary.
  • Accordingly, the Technical Bid rejection was lawful; WPA 32253 of 2026 is dismissed.
  • No order can be passed against the GeM portal as no relief was sought against it.
  • An urgent certified copy of the order may be issued upon compliance with formalities.

Topics: Bank Guarantee, Public Procurement, Legal Dispute