Authority: High Court of Judicature at Madras
Order Date: 17-11-2026
Case Overview
- Petitioner: Dr. Shruti Yeddula, seeking permission to appear for the Third‑Year Post‑Graduate University Examination scheduled to commence on 03.08.2026.
- Respondents: 1) Medical Council of India, 2) Chettinad Hospital and Research Institute, 3) Controller of Examinations, Chettinad Hospital and Research Institute, 4) The Dean (Medical), Chettinad Hospital and Research Institute.
- Nature of Proceeding: Writ Petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of India for issuance of a writ of mandamus directing the respondents to allow the petitioner to remit the examination fee, download the hall ticket, and write the examination without reference to alleged attendance deficiency.
- Background Facts:
- Petitioner completed MBBS at SRM Medical College Hospital and Research Centre in 2022 and began her M.S. (General Surgery) in September 2023 at the second respondent university.
- Prior to the exam on 03.08.2026, she could not pay the fee online nor generate a hall ticket because the college claimed she had not met the minimum attendance requirement.
- The petitioner attempted to convince the university of meeting the requirement; no response was received. Her father met the Dean, who reiterated the attendance condition.
- Interim Relief: The Court, by an interim order dated 31.07.2026, permitted the petitioner to sit the examination and directed the respondents to enable fee payment and issue the hall ticket, stating the order was purely interim and did not confer any substantive right.
- Post‑Exam Situation: The petitioner has written the examination, but the university is withholding her results. The statutory attendance requirement for a three‑year postgraduate course is 751 working days (80% of 939 days). The university claims the petitioner attended only 707 days up to 30.06.2026, indicating a shortfall of 44 days.
- Contentions:
- Petitioner’s Counsel: Argues the petitioner attended more than 751 days; points to discrepancies between manual registers and biometric records; asserts that the biometric system shows 00.00 hours for several days due to simultaneous punch‑in and punch‑out, which were nonetheless counted in the 707 days.
- Respondents’ Counsel: Emphasizes the importance of the attendance rule for competence; maintains biometric records are indisputable; states the 707‑day count is accurate up to 30.06.2026 and that any attendance after that date must be verified.
- Regulatory Framework: National Medical Commission (NMC) Post‑Graduate Medical Education Regulations, 2023 prescribe the attendance requirement and allow extension of training by the number of excess leave days taken.
Final Outcome
- The Court directs the respondents to take into account the petitioner’s attendance after 30.06.2026. If the additional attendance makes up the 44‑day shortfall, the university must publish her examination results forthwith.
- If the shortfall remains, the results shall be published immediately upon completion of the remaining required training days.
- The writ petition is disposed of with no costs awarded to either party.
Topics: Court Order, Medical Education Attendance, Examination Results