Authority: Supreme Court of India
Order Date: 17 November 2026
Case Overview
- Parties: BSE Ltd (Appellant) vs. Spice Energy Pvt. Ltd. (Respondent) and an additional respondent.
- Background: On 14 January 2023 the Surveillance Cell of National Securities Depository Limited froze SEPL’s demat account. BSE’s Review Committee rejected SEPL’s request to de‑freeze on 26 April 2023. SEPL appealed to the Securities Appellate Tribunal (SAT) (Appeal No. 569/2023).
- SAT Decision (30 April 2025): The SAT allowed the appeal, quashed the BSE Review Committee order, directed BSE to refund the entire amount realized from SEPL concerning outstanding Annual Listing Fees (ALF) of Cals Refineries Limited with interest, and ordered immediate de‑freezing of SEPL’s demat account. Costs of ₹1,00,000 were awarded to SEPL.
- Legal Reasoning by SAT: SAT held that Cals Refineries Limited was under the Corporate Insolvency Resolution Process (CIRP) under the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016 (IBC) after a petition was admitted on 17 October 2017 under Section 9. It applied Section 14 of the IBC (moratorium) and Section 238 (IBC prevails over inconsistent laws) to conclude that recovery of ALF dues could not be pursued against the erstwhile promoter of the corporate debtor. The SAT rejected BSE’s argument that the moratorium applied only to the corporate debtor and not to its promoters.
- Court’s Observations: The Supreme Court found SAT’s construction of Section 14 contrary to its language, stating the moratorium applies solely to the corporate debtor, not to promoters or directors. The Court also noted SAT failed to consider the applicability of SEBI (Listing Obligations and Disclosure Requirements) Regulations, 2015 circulars, and other issues raised by SEPL.
- Interim Orders: An interim order dated 10 February 2026 (I.A. No. 203072/2025) modified an earlier interim order of 30 May 2025, permitting de‑freezing of SEPL’s demat account upon deposit of ₹58,04,505 with BSE, “without prejudice and under protest.” SEPL complied and paid the amount to BSE.
Final Outcome
- The Supreme Court set aside the SAT’s impugned order dated 30 April 2025 and remanded the matter to the SAT for fresh consideration on merits, directing that the SAT must address all issues, including SEPL’s claim for refund of ALF dues with interest.
- The Court clarified that the ₹58,04,505 already paid by SEPL will be subject to the final result of the SAT’s fresh consideration.
- The appeal is disposed of; each party bears its own costs, and any pending applications are dismissed.
Topics: Capital Markets, Insolvency