Authority: Calcutta High Court
Order Date: 17 November 2026
Case Overview
- Petitioners: Dhoot Realtors Pvt. Ltd (company) and its director (Petitioner No. 2); Opposite party: Apurba Kumar Jana.
- Revisional application filed under CrPC Sec 482 (corresponding to Sec 528 BNSS, 2023) seeking quash of complaint case No. 3407/2022, originally filed under IPC Sec 406/420 before Judicial Magistrate, 1st Class, Bidhannagar, North 24 Parganas.
- Complaint dated 24 August 2022 alleged cheating and criminal breach of trust for non‑payment of balance ₹10,27,840 on a landscaping work order dated 7 Jan 2024 (and another on 14 Jan 2020) for project “Prathama” at 26 B.T. Road, Kolkata. Total bill ₹27,77,840; petitioner paid ₹17,50,000.
- Notices served on 26 Aug 2020, 3 Dec 2020, legal notice on 19 July 2021; complaint lodged with police on 10 May 2022; magistrate ordered process on 9 Apr 2024; petitioner’s appearance exempted on 7 Nov 2024.
- Petitioners argued lack of mens rea, that the dispute is civil, no entrustment, and that the magistrate’s order lacked reasons, citing Supreme Court judgments (Sunil Bharti Mittal v CBI, State of Haryana v Bhajanlal, etc.).
- Opposite party contended intentional deception and non‑payment despite repeated demands.
- Court examined statutory elements of IPC Sec 415 (cheating) and Sec 406 (criminal breach of trust), emphasizing need for fraudulent intent and entrustment, and referenced multiple Supreme Court decisions (V. Ganesan, Iridium India Telecom Ltd v Motorola Inc., Vijay Kumar Ghai, Hriday Ranjan Prasad Verma, etc.) that distinguish civil breach of contract from criminal cheating.
- Court concluded that the complaint contains no allegation of fraud or dishonest inducement, and no entrustment of property; therefore ingredients of offences under Sec 420 and Sec 406 are absent.
Final Outcome
- The revisional application is allowed.
- Complaint case No. 3407/2022 under Sec 406/420 IPC pending before the Judicial Magistrate, Bidhannagar, is quashed.
- All connected applications, if any, are disposed of.
- Certified copies of the order to be supplied upon compliance with formalities.
Topics: Criminal Procedure, Contract Dispute, Judicial Review