Authority: Supreme Court of India

Order Date: 19 November 2026

Case Overview

  • Parties: The Gem and Jewellery Export Promotion Council (appellant) versus the State of Maharashtra and other respondents.
  • Nature of Proceeding: Civil Appeal No. 1889 of 2015 challenging the High Court judgment and earlier orders of the Divisional Commissioner (Konkan Division, Mumbai) and the Additional Collector, Mumbai Suburban District, concerning the applicability of the Bombay Entertainments Duty Act, 1923 to the Council’s trade exhibitions.
  • Background:
  • The Council organizes the India International Jewellery Show (IIJS) and IIJS Signature, large B2B trade exhibitions.
  • Under the 1960 Rules for Licensing and Controlling Places of Public Amusement, a police NOC was required. The Council paid Rs 38,91,250 (later Rs 62,76,875) under protest for the NOC for the August 2011 show.
  • Subsequent demands led to additional deposits of Rs 11,96,938 for the 2012 exhibition and a refund claim on 24‑01‑2012.
  • The Additional Collector issued an Assessment Order demanding Rs 1,32,47,750 for IIJS 2011; the Bombay High Court quashed this order on 10‑05‑2012 and again on 20‑07‑2012.
  • On 31‑07‑2012 the Collector fixed liability at Rs 97,09,500, adjusting the protest payment and demanding a balance of Rs 34,32,625.
  • The High Court, on 17‑08‑2012, directed the police to grant an NOC without a Collector’s NOC and allowed the Council to deposit Rs 94,32,625 (Rs 34,32,625 arrears + Rs 60,00,000 advance for IIJS 2012).
  • The Divisional Commissioner, on 30‑11‑2012, reduced the assessment to Rs 45,40,125, deleted the penalty on 919 surplus passes, and ordered a refund of Rs 51,69,250.
  • The Council filed W.P. No. 653 of 2013 seeking declaration that the exhibitions are not “entertainment” under the Act and a quashing of the 31‑07‑2012 and 30‑11‑2012 orders.
  • Legal Issue: Whether the pure B2B trade exhibitions (IIJS and IIJS Signature) fall within the definition of “entertainment” under Section 2(a) of the Bombay Entertainments Duty Act, 1923 and are therefore liable to entertainment duty under Section 3.
  • Counsel: Aman Raj Gandhi (appellant) and Bharat Bagla (respondents) appeared before the Court.

Final Outcome

  • The Supreme Court dismissed the appeal, holding that the exhibitions constitute “entertainment” because they are exhibitions to which persons are admitted for payment, satisfying the statutory definition in Section 2(a).
  • The Court affirmed the liability of Rs 45,40,125 entertainment duty for IIJS 2011 and upheld the High Court’s findings that the exhibitions are taxable despite being restricted to trade participants.
  • The requirement of a police NOC without a Collector’s NOC was rejected, confirming the earlier orders directing the Council to comply with the duty.
  • The judgment emphasizes that admission fees, commercial gains, and the scale of the event (budget > Rs 20 crore, 1,600 stalls costing Rs 150‑200 crore, trade orders > Rs 5,000 crore) satisfy the “entertainment” test, and the absence of performances or fashion shows does not exempt the event.

Topics: Entertainment Duty, Trade Exhibition Taxation