Authority: High Court of Jammu & Kashmir and Ladakh, Srinagar

Order Date: 20.11.2026

Case Overview

  • Petitioners: Zahida Mushtaq (through counsel M. Y. Bhat et al.) vs. Union Territory of J&K and others (including National Highway Authority, District Magistrate Pulwama, etc.).
  • The petitioner operates "M/S Fatima Filling Station" at Khasra Nos. 7489, 7190, 7492, 7493, Village Letpora, Tehsil Pampore, established under Petroleum Act, 1934 and Petroleum Rules, 2002.
  • Access permission from NHAI was initially granted via letter No.NHAI/RO-Jammu/2013/11051/NOC/395 dated 25.02.2021, allowing use of an approach road carved out of NHAI land.
  • On 28.07.2025 NHAI issued a communication directing the Chief Manager, Retail Sales of Indian Oil Corp to deposit a penalty of Rs.2,50,000 and to de‑energise the outlet until final NOC is obtained.
  • The petitioner challenged the penalty, alleging encroachments on National Highway land by third parties prevented construction of the access road, and that the penalty was therefore unjust.
  • The Supreme Court in Gyan Prakash vs. Union of India (20.02.2024) issued directions for removal of highway encroachments; NHAI issued a circular dated 26.06.2020 (para 2.11(v)) prescribing a Rs.2.5 lakh penalty for operating an energized fuel station without prior access permission.
  • The petitioner had deposited the penalty on 31.07.2025, claiming she is therefore barred from challenging the communication.
  • Earlier related writ petition WP(C) No.1919/2025 (disposed on 12.08.2025) directed the District Magistrate, Pulwama, to examine all requisite NOCs and allow operation only if they were complete; an interim order dated 26.09.2025 had temporarily protected the petitioner’s operation.
  • The District Magistrate’s subsequent order dated 10.12.2025 was held in abeyance by this Court on 30.09.2026.
  • The petitioner’s licence expired on 31.12.2025 and was not renewed.
  • Respondent No.12 (Zaffar Ahmad Lone) raised a preliminary objection, claiming the petitioner suppressed the 12.08.2025 order; the Court found non‑materiality of that omission.
  • The Court examined the MoRTH guidelines (circular No.RW‑NH‑33032/01/2017/S&R(R) dated 26.06.2020) which state that provisional permission does not allow energisation; only regular access permission may.
  • It was established that the petitioner had not obtained final access permission; therefore the penalty was legally justified.
  • Encroachments on highway land remain unresolved; the District Magistrate is empowered under the Control of National Highways (Land and Traffic) Act, 2002 to remove them.

Final Outcome

1. The penalty of Rs.2.5 lakh imposed on Indian Oil Corporation by the communication dated 28.07.2025 is upheld.

2. The District Magistrate/Deputy Commissioner, Pulwama, is directed to conduct an enquiry to determine whether the petitioner has installed the petrol pump at the sanctioned location in compliance with all required NOCs.

3. If the enquiry finds compliance, the petitioner shall be allowed to operate the pump; any encroachment on National Highway land preventing access must be removed by the District Magistrate/Deputy Commissioner pursuant to law.

4. Upon construction of the access road, the National Highway Authority shall grant the final access permission and permit energisation of the pump.

5. If the enquiry finds deficiencies, the petitioner shall be given time to remedy them; failure to do so will result in the pump being shut down or sealed.

Topics: Penalty Enforcement, Fuel Station NOC Compliance, Highway Encroachment Removal