Authority: Calcutta High Court, Civil Revisionary Jurisdiction (Appellate Side)
Order Date: 16.11.2026
Case Overview
- Parties: Petitioners – a group of six individuals (Mr. Suddhasatwa Banerjee, Mr. Shashwat Nayak, Mr. Sagnik Roy Chowdhury, Mr. Mitul Chakraborty, Ms. Payel Nath, Mr. Trijit Mitra); Respondent – Indian Bank (represented by Mr. Shiv Mangal Singh).
- Background: On 21.06.2021 the bank issued a notice under Section 13(2) of the SARFAESI Act demanding Rs 1,54,54,555. The bank subsequently invoked Section 13(4) on 12.12.2021. Petitioners filed SA No. 707 of 2021 before the Debt Recovery Tribunal‑III, Kolkata, challenging those measures.
- District Magistrate Proceedings: The bank filed an application under Section 14(1) on 21.09.2022. The District Magistrate (DM) issued an order authorising Shri Bimalendu Nath, WBCS (Executive), to take physical possession of two secured assets.
- Interlocutory Applications: Petitioners filed IA 226 of 2023 challenging the DM order. Meanwhile, one of the two secured assets was sold by the bank through an e‑auction on 05.04.2023, generating a sale certificate on 23.05.2023 showing receipt of Rs 33,50,000.
- DRAT Interim Order: On 10.05.2023 the Debt Recovery Appellate Tribunal (DRAT) passed an interim order in IA 226 of 2023, later modifying it to state that any further action by the bank would be subject to the outcome of the application.
- Second DM Order: On 30.10.2023 the bank sought further assistance; the DM issued another order on 28.11.2023 authorising Shri Prasun Kumar Dhara, WBCS (Executive), to take possession. This order again listed both assets and reiterated the outstanding amount of Rs 1,54,54,555, without adjusting for the Rs 33,50,000 already realised.
- Petitioners’ IA 170 of 2024: Filed on 01.02.2024, seeking quash of the 28.11.2023 DM order. The DRAT, by its judgment dated 30.08.2024, set aside the 01.02.2024 order and dismissed IA 170 of 2024, granting the bank liberty to proceed.
- Petitioners’ Arguments: Asserted that the DM became functus officio after the 21.09.2022 order was challenged before the DRT, that the DM’s 28.11.2023 order was ultra vires, and that the DRAT erred by not considering the miscarriage of justice.
- Bank’s Arguments: Contended that Section 14 deals only with possession of secured assets, not the quantum of debt; the DM’s role is ministerial and execution‑ary, requiring no affidavit after the initial one; and the DM’s second order was a permissible incidental step under Section 14(2).
- Legal Points Discussed: Interpretation of Sections 14(1) and 14(2) of the SARFAESI Act; the concept of functus officio for the magistrate; the limited jurisdiction of the DM to assist in possession, not to adjudicate debt amounts; reference to Section 21 of the General Clauses Act; and distinction from earlier case law (CO 3813 2024) which was later set aside by the Supreme Court on 10.04.2026.
Final Outcome
- The High Court dismissed C.O. 3787 of 2024, upholding the validity of the DM’s original 21.09.2022 order and rejecting the petitioners’ claim of jurisdictional overreach.
- The court concluded that the magistrate’s powers under Section 14 are strictly ministerial, that the DM was not functus officio until the secured assets were fully delivered, and that the DRAT’s reversal of the DRT order was not liable to interference.
- Consequently, the petitioners’ revision application was dismissed, and the bank’s right to proceed under the SARFAESI framework was affirmed.
Topics: SARFAESI Act, Debt Recovery, Judicial Review