Authority: Calcutta High Court (High Court at Calcutta)
Order Date: 16 November 2026
Case Overview
- Petitioner: Prasun Kanti Mondal, represented by counsel Nilanjan Pal and Shreejita Sen, filed WPA No. 14425 of 2024 seeking quash of IOC letter dated 19 February 2024 that categorized his LPG distributorship as Gramin Vitarak; he claimed entitlement to Rurban Vitarak for the Barrackpore‑Kalyani Expressway location.
- Respondents: Indian Oil Corporation Limited (IOC) and its officials, represented by counsel Manwendra Singh Yadav and Saswati Chatterjee; also the Union of India represented by counsel Debjani Ghosal and Sanchayita Das.
- Background: Applicant applied in 2007 for LPG distributorship under SC category (Rural market) at Barrackpore/Kalyani Highway; LOI issued on 28 Jan 2013 and revised on 8 Mar 2013. Earlier writ petitions (2010, 2012) led to a coordinated bench order on 28 June 2019 directing reconsideration; on 11 Nov 2019 petitioner was awarded the distributorship after another candidate’s cancellation.
- Subsequent developments: petitioner filed RTI on 1 Dec 2023; reply on 19 Dec 2023 (ref No. IOC/2100000255). First Appellate Authority order on 6 Feb 2024 required IOC to supply relevant extract of Unified Guidelines 2022; IOC complied on 19 Feb 2024 but withheld full internal manual, citing internal‑use restriction.
- Petitioner alleged that clause 6.2.1 of the Guidelines was not disclosed and that the categorisation to Gramin Vitarak was arbitrary, seeking re‑classification to Rurban Vitarak and quashing of the 19 Feb 2024 letter.
- Respondent arguments: petitioner originally applied for Rural (Gramin) category; LOI and advertisement of 16 Sep 2007 specified Rural market; Unified Guidelines 2022 (and earlier 2016) define three categories—Sheheri (Urban), Rurban (Urban‑Rural), Gramin (Rural). Petitioner's affidavit admitted Rural area; therefore he cannot later claim Rurban. The RTI response merely supplied the requested extract and does not affect his rights.
- Court’s analysis: examined advertisement, application, LOIs, prior orders, and the Unified Guidelines 2022; found petitioner applied for and was empanelled under Rural (now termed Gramin Vitarak). The power to declare an area as rural or urban lies with the Registrar General and Census Commissioner, not with IOC; however the classification in dispute is internal market type, not a statutory census classification. The RTI response does not constitute a decision affecting the distributorship. No prejudice shown; petitioner has not complied with other setup requirements.
Final Outcome
- The Court dismissed WPA No. 14425 of 2024 without costs; all reliefs sought were denied; interim orders, if any, were vacated; parties directed to download the judgment from the official Calcutta High Court website.
Topics: LPG Distributorship, Judicial Decision