Authority: High Court of Jharkhand at Ranchi

Order Date: 20 November 2026

Case Overview

  • Contempt petition (Cont. Case (Civil) No. 1041 of 2026) filed by M/s Dhananjay Yadav (through partner Dhananjay Yadav) against the State of Jharkhand, Sri Sanjay Kujur (Executive Director, JSBCCL), Sri Arwa Raj Mamal (Managing Director, JSBCCL), and Sri Uma Shankar Singh (Secretary, Department of School Education and Literacy), alleging wilful and deliberate disobedience of the order dated 07‑12‑2022 passed in W.P. (C) No. 4001 of 2022.
  • Opposite parties Nos. 2 & 3 filed a show‑cause affidavit on 18‑11‑2026, stating they acknowledge the corporation’s obligation to pay the unpaid principal balance but cannot release payment because the revised expenditure exceeds the existing administrative approval and the revised administrative approval and corresponding budgetary allotment have not yet been communicated.
  • Original administrative approval for each of the two projects was Rs 4,48,29,439.89. The technically approved revised estimate for the Chainpur project is Rs 6,19,89,500.00 (approximately 38.28% above the administrative approval). The revised estimate for the Albert Ekka Jari project is Rs 5,82,97,100.00 (approximately 30.04% above the administrative approval). Variations arose due to frame‑structure works and the hilly site conditions.
  • Paragraph 183(a) of the Jharkhand Public Works Department Code, 2012 requires submission of a revised estimate where the administratively approved estimate is likely to be exceeded by more than 20%. Paragraph 123 further provides for revised administrative approval by the competent authority and the requisite budgetary allotment where the approved amount is likely to be exceeded by more than 20%.
  • The corporation submitted letters dated 21‑05‑2026, 09‑07‑2026 and 10‑07‑2026 to the Secretary, Department of School Education and Literacy, requesting revised administrative approval and fund allocation, referencing the order dated 10‑04‑2026 and the six‑week deadline.
  • Interlocutory application I.A. No. 16251 of 2026 was filed on behalf of opposite party No. 4 (Secretary) seeking deletion from the contempt petition, arguing that the Secretary was not a respondent in the original writ proceeding.
  • The Court, after hearing counsel, observed that the payment to the petitioner is dependent upon revised administrative approval and fund allocation, and that party 4 was not a respondent in the original writ; consequently, continuation of the contempt petition serves no useful purpose.

Final Outcome

  • The contempt proceedings against all opposite parties are hereby dropped.
  • The present contempt case stands disposed of.
  • The petitioner is at liberty to take appropriate recourse as permissible under law for redressal of its subsisting grievance.
  • Interlocutory application I.A. No. 16251 of 2026 also stands disposed of.

Topics: Contempt Proceedings, Public Works Administration, Judicial Orders