Authority: Supreme Court of India

Order Date: 28 October 2026

Case Overview

  • Parties: Appellant M/S Kalindi Associates; Respondents M/S Bharat Commerce and Industries Limited (in liquidation) and others, including a non‑participant respondent No.2 and the Official Liquidator.
  • Background: Bharat Commerce and Industries Ltd underwent liquidation. An e‑auction on 29 Jan 2025 of Plot Nos. 45‑A & B, 47‑55 (≈ 2,40,500 sq ft) in Rajpura, Punjab was conducted. Kalindi Associates was the highest bidder with an offer of Rs 31,00,00,000 (Rs 31 crore) against a reserve price of Rs 29 crore and later expressed willingness to raise its bid to Rs 35 crore.
  • A third party, M/s Maa Sharda Oils, submitted a higher offer of Rs 35 crore. The Madhya Pradesh High Court (single judge) rejected this third‑party offer on 27 Sep 2025 but directed the liquidator to inquire if Kalindi would revise its bid to Rs 35 crore. Kalindi indicated willingness to enhance its bid (the document mistakenly mentions Rs 35,00,000, i.e., Rs 35 lakhs, but the intended amount is Rs 35 crore).
  • Respondent No.2, a stranger to the auction, filed Interlocutory Application No. 170/2026 offering Rs 42.25 crore. The single judge dismissed the application on 16 Mar 2026. The Division Bench of the High Court, however, on 23 Apr 2026 remanded the matter for fresh consideration and directed the liquidator to refrain from executing the sale deed.
  • The appellant filed Review Petition No. 954/2026; the Division Bench dismissed it on 11 May 2026, holding that the earlier remand order did not merit interference.
  • The Supreme Court, after hearing senior counsel for all parties and reviewing the record, held that respondent No.2 was a “stranger” with no locus standi to intervene, as it neither participated in the auction nor made any bid on the auction date.
  • The Court relied on precedents (Jasbhai Motibhai Desai vs Roshan Kumar, Nagar Rice v. N.T. Gowda, Golden Food Products India vs State of U.P., Eva Agro Feeds Pvt Ltd vs Punjab National Bank) emphasizing the sanctity of a public auction, the requirement of a material irregularity to set aside a highest bid, and the necessity of a proper reason for rejecting a valid bid.

Final Outcome

  • The Supreme Court set aside the impugned order of the High Court Division Bench.
  • It dismissed Interlocutory Application No. 170/2026 filed by respondent No.2.
  • The appeals filed by Kalindi Associates were allowed.
  • The Official Liquidator was directed to hand over possession of the subject land to Kalindi Associates immediately after completion of all legal formalities, including registration of the sale deed.
  • All pending applications, including the intervention application, were ordered to stand disposed of.
  • No costs were awarded.

Topics: Auction Law, Locus Standi