Authority: High Court of Karnataka, Bengaluru
Order Date: 21 November 2026
Case Overview
- Petitioners: Dr. Sonal Asthana, Dr. Kaisar Raja, Dr. Rajiv Lochan (all doctors) and Marlene Venkata, filing Criminal Petition No. 35 of 2022 under Section 482 of the Criminal Procedure Code.
- Respondents: State of Karnataka (represented by Kengeri Police Station) and Dr. Vijay Vemuri, CEO, BGS Hospital, Bengaluru.
- Underlying Criminal Proceedings: C.C. No. 26322/2018 before the Additional Chief Metropolitan Magistrate Court, Bengaluru, charging the petitioners under Sections 43A and 66 of the Information Technology Act and Section 408 of the Indian Penal Code.
- Factual Matrix: The complainant (respondent No.2) alleged that the petitioners, engaged as retainers for liver transplantation services, stole and deleted patient data from the hospital’s computer system, compromising data integrity and the hospital’s reputation. Police registered Crime No. 335/2015, seized a 320 GB hard disk, and filed a charge sheet.
- Petitioners’ Contentions:
- They are retainers, not clerks or servants, thus Section 408 IPC (criminal breach of trust) should not apply.
- No certified electronic evidence under Section 65B of the Evidence Act was produced; the CD’s contents were not linked to them, so Section 66 IT Act cannot be invoked.
- Hospital’s HIS is password‑protected; no data export or deletion is possible; allegations are fabricated to avoid payment of Rs 70,00,000 owed to them.
- Respondents’ Contentions:
- Retainers had dominion over patient data; breach of trust under Section 408 IPC and unauthorized access under Section 66 IT Act are applicable.
- Data theft constitutes a serious economic offence; the complaint is bona‑fide and not barred by Section 482 CrPC.
- Court’s Observations:
1. The definition of Section 408 IPC includes “clerk or servant”; however, the petitioners, though retainers, exercised control over hospital data, satisfying the statutory ingredients.
2. Lack of a Section 65B certificate at the pleading stage does not preclude admissibility; the certificate may be produced at trial, as held in M.R. Hiremath vs. State.
3. Precedents (Madras High Court O.A.No.3/2023, WOLFGANG PROCK‑SCHAUER vs. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA 2024 SCC) affirm that unauthorized access and data extraction attract penalties under Sections 43 and 66 of the IT Act.
4. The allegations of data theft and deletion are prima facie offences; the matter is suitable for trial, not for dismissal under Section 482.
Final Outcome
- The Court dismissed Criminal Petition No. 35 of 2022, refusing to quash the proceedings in C.C. No. 26322/2018. The criminal case against the petitioners will continue.
Topics: Legal Proceedings, Data Privacy, Healthcare