Authority: High Court of Karnataka, Bengaluru
Order Date: 18 November 2026
Case Overview
- Parties: Appellants – Deputy Commissioner of Commercial Taxes (Audit) Bengaluru and Deputy Commissioner of Commercial Taxes (Audit and Recovery) Belagavi; Respondents – M/s Shree Renuka Sugars Ltd (represented by Deputy General Manager Finance, Shri Rahul Patil), Karnataka State Beverages Corporation Ltd (KSBCL) and its Executive Director (O).
- The matter comprised three pending proceedings: Writ Appeal No.1153/2025 (Excise), Writ Appeal No.677/2026 (T‑RES), and Sales Tax Revision Petition No.15/2026 (STRP), all arising from a tax dispute over the export of 3,000 MT of denatured ethanol anhydrous to M/s Kolmar Group (Switzerland) in 2013.
- SRSL had furnished an indemnity bond dated 17‑08‑2013 to KSBCL; KSBCL invoked the bond after the Revenue issued a reassessment order on 21‑10‑2016 under Section 9(2) of the CST Act, determining liability of ₹1,86,92,460 (tax + interest) for failure to file Form‑H.
- The First Appellate Authority dismissed KSBCL’s appeal on 31‑03‑2017; KSBCL then filed STA No.297/2017 before the Karnataka Appellate Tribunal (KAT). The Single Judge of the High Court, in W.P.No.9571/2017 (Excise), directed KAT to dispose of STA No.297/2017 in favour of KSBCL, holding that the goods were exported and the demand was unsustainable.
- The Revenue challenged that direction, filing W.A.No.1153/2025, arguing that filing Form‑H was mandatory. The Single Judge also allowed W.P.No.25944/2025 on 04‑09‑2025, directing KAT to comply with the 21‑Oct‑2024 order.
- KAT subsequently disposed of STA No.297/2017 in favour of KSBCL on 12‑09‑2025, relying on the Single Judge’s orders. The Revenue filed STRP No.15/2026 under Section 65(1) of the KVAT Act, seeking to set aside the KAT order.
Final Outcome
- The Court condoned the delay in filing both writ appeals (IA No.1/2025 and IA No.1/2026).
- The impugned order dated 21‑Oct‑2024 (W.P.No.9571/2017) is set aside and the matter remanded to the Single Judge for fresh consideration, including whether the inter‑party dispute may be heard under Article 226.
- Consequently, the order dated 04‑Sep‑2025 (W.P.No.25944/2025) is also set aside and stands disposed of.
- The KAT order dated 12‑Sep‑2025 (STA No.297/2017) is set aside; the appeal is restored before KAT for a fresh decision, uninfluenced by the Court’s orders.
- The Revenue’s Sales Tax Revision Petition (STRP No.15/2026) is allowed; the appeals W.A.No.1153/2025, W.A.No.677/2026 and the STRP are allowed in the terms stated.
- All pending applications are disposed of. The Court expressly refrains from opining on whether filing Form‑H is mandatory or whether KSBCL is entitled to the deemed‑export benefit.
Topics: Tax Litigation, Excise & Customs, Form‑H Requirement