Authority: High Court of Uttarakhand at Nainital
Order Date: 19 November 2026
Case Overview
- Petition: Writ Petition (M/B) No.552 of 2024 filed by M/s Kunwar Construction (Petitioner) against State of Uttarakhand and others (Respondents).
- Relief Sought: (i) Quash technical bid rejection order dated 08‑11‑2024; (i‑a) Quash complaint rejection order dated 05‑12‑2024; (ii) Direct declaration of petitioner’s technical bid as responsive and successful, inclusion in Stage‑I technical list, and subsequent award of contract to lowest financial bidder for NIT‑08(P‑III)/2024‑25 (Package UT‑09512) – construction of MRL‑15 Kalika to Talla Khumti Motor Road Upgradation (4.675 km) in District Pithoragarh, Circle Dharchula.
- Tender Process: E‑tender notice dated 11‑09‑2024 issued by Uttarakhand Rural Roads Development Agency (URRDA). Technical bid of petitioner rejected by Bid Evaluation Committee on 08‑11‑2024 on three grounds:
1. Insufficient similar‑nature work experience (ITB Sec 2 Clause 4.2(c)).
2. Methodology bar chart not as per work requirement.
3. No affidavit on Vehicle Tracking System/GPS as required by NIT footnote S.N.21.
- Petitioner's Arguments: Asserted compliance with all technical requirements; provided experience certificates covering Stage‑I and Stage‑II work (including Water Bounding Material – WBM); submitted methodology chart on page 170 and affidavits on pages 172‑175, which were allegedly overlooked.
- Respondents' Counter‑arguments: Experience certificates only covered hillside cutting, retaining walls, etc. (Stage‑I) and lacked required Stage‑II experience (Bituminous Concrete work). Methodology chart sequence violated Item 7 vs Item 6. Affidavit did not meet footnote 21 requirements.
- Relevant Tender Clauses: SBD Clause 4 (Qualification of Bidder) – especially 4.2(c) (experience of similar work) and 4.4A(b) (minimum experience value). NIT points 17‑18 stipulate need for both Stage‑I and Stage‑II experience; only Bituminous Concrete, Semi‑Dense Bituminous Concrete, Mixed Seal Surfacing, or Open Graded Premix Carpet qualify as “similar work”.
- Legal Precedents Cited: Central Coalfields Ltd. v. SLL‑SML (2016), Afcons Infra Ltd. v. Nagpur Metro Rail Corp. (2016), Raunaq International Ltd. v. I.V.R. Construction Ltd. (1999), Air India Ltd. v. Cochin International Airport Ltd. (2000), N.G. Projects Ltd. v. Vinod Kumar Jain (2022), Tata Motors Ltd. v. BEST (2023). These cases emphasize limited judicial interference in tender evaluations absent mala‑fide, arbitrariness, or irrationality.
- Court’s Reasoning: Found that petitioner’s experience did not include any Bituminous Concrete work, which is the only qualifying Stage‑II work per Clause 4.4(a)&(b). Determined that the affidavit required by footnote 21 was not submitted. Concluded that the Bid Evaluation Committee acted within its authority, provided cogent reasons, and there was no mala‑fide or irrationality.
Final Outcome
- The High Court dismissed the writ petition, holding that the technical bid rejection and subsequent complaint rejection were lawful and substantiated.
- All pending applications, if any, were also disposed of.
- The original technical bid rejection stands, and the tender process proceeds without the petitioner.
Topics: Public Procurement, Infrastructure Tender