Authority: High Court of Judicature at Madras
Order Date: 20-11-2026
Case Overview
- Parties: Plaintiffs – Kamakshi Kumaran, M/s Sree Builders (represented by the deceased proprietor V. Radhakrishna through power agent Mrs. Kamakshi Kumaran), R. Suchitra, V.R. Vighnesh, V.R. Vaishnave; Defendants – Venkatramani, the late C.R. Chandrasekaran, C.R. Revathi alias Gowri Chandrasekaran, C. Kirupa Shankar, and Sowmiya Srikanthan (as LRs of the deceased).
- Nature of Proceeding: Original Side Appeal No. 69 of 2024 filed under Order XXXVI Rule 9 of the OS Rules, seeking to set aside the judgment and decree dated 10‑07‑2023 passed by the learned Single Judge in C.S. No. 82 of 2007.
- Background: A sale agreement dated 21‑07‑2005 between the plaintiffs and the first defendant for the transfer of a suit property for a total consideration of Rs 59 lakhs. The agreement required an advance of Rs 10 lakhs (paid by cheque No. 093345 on 21‑07‑2005) and the balance of Rs 49 lakhs within 90 days, subject to the vendor clearing an existing mortgage with Bank of India (Cathedral Road branch) and producing original title deeds.
- The first defendant claimed the original title deeds were held as security for a loan of Rs 8 lakhs with the Bank of India and asked the plaintiffs to provide Rs 10 lakhs to enable discharge of the mortgage. The plaintiffs paid the advance but the defendant failed to discharge the loan, did not produce the original deeds, and allegedly negotiated with third parties.
- The plaintiffs issued a legal notice on 26‑02‑2006 demanding performance; the defendant replied alleging termination of the agreement for non‑performance by the plaintiffs. The plaintiffs further lodged a police complaint on 15‑12‑2006.
- Defendants 2 and 3 later entered into a separate sale deed on 08‑12‑2008 for Rs 96 lakhs, subsequently settling the property in favour of defendant 4 on 08‑06‑2011, creating additional encumbrance.
- The Single Judge dismissed the suit for specific performance and granted alternate relief directing the first defendant to pay Rs 10 lakhs with interest at 7.5 % per annum on Rs 2 lakhs from 07‑12‑2005 until payment.
- Appeal Contentions: Plaintiffs argued they were ready and willing, that time was not an essential term, and that the vendor was obligated under Section 13(c) of the Specific Relief Act to redeem the mortgage. The first defendant contended the plaintiffs lacked capacity to pay the balance, that the advance was misused, and that the plaintiffs never demonstrated readiness and willingness.
- The Court examined extensive oral and documentary evidence, including bank statements showing negligible balances in the plaintiffs’ accounts, the absence of any payment of the remaining consideration, and the fact that the mortgage remained unpaid.
- The Court referenced several Supreme Court precedents on specific performance, the necessity of continuous readiness and willingness, the effect of limitation periods, and the discretionary nature of granting specific performance.
Final Outcome
- The appeal is dismissed; the judgment and decree of the learned Single Judge dated 10‑07‑2023 are confirmed.
- The alternate relief of Rs 10 lakhs with interest at 7.5 % on Rs 2 lakhs from 07‑12‑2005 remains in force.
- No costs are awarded to either side.
- The connected miscellaneous petition is closed.
Topics: Specific Performance, Property Sale Dispute