Authority: High Court of Judicature at Madras
Order Date: 17-11-2026
Case Overview
- Parties: Petitioner P. Srinivasan (son of P. Padmanabhan) versus Respondents: Sharvika Properties (represented by Managing Partner B. Gopi), K.N. Sampath, Swastic Homes (partner K. Ravichandran), and M. Ravindran. The deceased Jayashree Ravindran is also mentioned.
- Nature of Proceeding: Civil revision petition (CRP No.5290 of 2026) filed under Article 227 of the Constitution of India against the order dated 07‑02‑2026 passed by the Principal District Court, Kancheepuram in I.A.No.5 of 2025, O.S.No.335 of 2023. The revision was converted to a petition under Section 115 of the CPC.
- Background: The suit before the District Court sought specific performance of an oral agreement for the sale of a suit property originally owned by Ms. P. Ramalakshmi (sister of the petitioner). Key chronological events:
- May 2016 – Ms. Ramalakshmi orally agreed to sell the property to the second respondent (K.N. Sampath) for Rs 95 lakhs, paid via the third defendant (PoA agent).
- 21‑05‑2018 – Ms. Ramalakshmi died; her heirs, including the petitioner, released their shares to the petitioner to enable the sale.
- 02‑03‑2021 – Second respondent executed a written sale agreement with the first respondent (Sharvika Properties) for Rs 9.05 crore (Rs 3.90 crore payable to second respondent, Rs 5.15 crore to petitioner).
- 28‑06‑2022 – Fresh agreement altered the amount payable to the petitioner to Rs 5.25 crore; demand drafts totalling Rs 5 crore were issued to the petitioner on 28‑06‑2022.
- Relief Sought in the Suit:
a) Specific performance of the oral agreement and written agreements dated 02‑03‑2021 and 28‑06‑2022, directing the petitioner to execute and register the sale deed for Rs 9.05 crore.
b) Payment of Rs 5 lakhs with 18% per annum interest to the plaintiff.
c) Compensation of Rs 1 crore for breach of contract.
- Petitioner’s Application for Rejection: Filed under Order VII Rule 11 CPC, arguing no cause of action, illusory claim, and that the alleged agreement was only between petitioner and second respondent, not with the plaintiff.
- Court Below’s Reasoning: Found averments of an oral agreement between plaintiff and petitioner, supported by documents, indicating a triable issue requiring evidence; therefore, the plaint disclosed a cause of action and could not be summarily dismissed.
- High Court’s Observations: The High Court affirmed that the issue of oral agreement is a matter of fact requiring trial, and the lower court’s finding was not perverse or illegal. It emphasized that the Court must limit its examination to pleadings and documents, not merits.
Final Outcome
- The civil revision petition is dismissed.
- The impugned order dated 07‑02‑2026 of the Principal District Court, Kancheepuram is sustained.
- No costs are awarded.
- Connected CMP Nos. 22993 and 26950 are closed.
Topics: Civil Procedure, Specific Performance, Property Sale