Authority: High Court of Meghalaya at Shillong

Order Date: 17 November 2026

Case Overview

  • Petitioner: Megha Technical and Engineers Pvt. Ltd., a company incorporated under the Companies Act, 1956, represented by authorized signatory Sanjib Kumar Saharia and counsel Dr. A.K. Saraf with Mr. S.J. Saikia.
  • Respondents: State of Meghalaya, Commissioner of Taxes, and Superintendent of Taxes, East Jaintia Hills District.
  • The writ petition (WP(C) No. 60 of 2024) challenged assessment orders issued under Section 9 of the Central Sales Tax Act, 1956 read with Section 45 of the Meghalaya VAT Act, 2003 for quarters ending 30‑06‑2007 to 30‑06‑2017.
  • Petitioner argued that the Superintendent’s orders were ultra‑violet because (i) the pre‑conditions of Section 45—absence of returns or unsatisfactory returns and a show‑cause notice—were not satisfied; (ii) the notice dated 27‑04‑2017 was issued under Section 55 for audit assessment, not Section 45; (iii) delegation of Section 45 powers to the Superintendent was not published in the Official Gazette as required by Section 26 and Rule 3; (iv) the five‑year limitation under Section 57 applies to assessments under Section 55 and therefore to the notice; and (v) natural justice was breached as no reasonable opportunity of hearing was afforded.
  • Respondents contended that the returns were accepted as correct, that Section 45 powers are “any period” without limitation, and that the notice complied with procedural requirements.
  • The Court examined the statutory language of Sections 45, 55, 57 and the MVAT Rules, finding that the notice sought production of books for audit purposes, thus falling under Section 55, and that no procedural rule exists for a best‑judgment assessment under Section 45. The Court held that the delegation under Section 26 was not valid without Gazette publication and that the five‑year limitation applies, rendering the assessment orders ultra‑violet and violative of natural justice.

Final Outcome

  • The assessment orders dated 07‑Nov‑2022 (quarter ending 30‑06‑2007 to 31‑03‑2010), 01‑Mar‑2023 (quarter ending 30‑06‑2010 to 31‑03‑2015) and 30‑Nov‑2023 (quarter ending 30‑06‑2015 to 30‑06‑2017) passed by the Superintendent of Taxes are set aside and quashed.
  • The writ petition is allowed and the case is disposed of.

Topics: Tax Assessment, Judicial Review