Authority: High Court of Judicature at Madras
Order Date: 19-11-2026
Case Overview
- Petitioners: Naresh M Mehta (Trustee of Mehta Family Trust and Mehta Diamond Trust) and Abhay S Mehta (Trustee of Mehta Family Trust, Mehta Diamond Trust, and Mehta Jewellery).
- Respondents: 1) Tuhin T Mehta (Trustee of Tushaar S Mehta Charitable Trust), 2) Rohan T Mehta (resident of New York), 3) Surendra M Mehta (deceased), 4) Sri RajaRajeshwari Hotels (Chennai) Pvt Ltd (represented by Managing Director Mr. A.C.S. Arunkumar), 5) Mehta Jewellery (represented by Abhay S Mehta & Naresh M Mehta).
- Civil Revision Petition No.4571 of 2023 & CMP No.27373 of 2023 filed under Article 227 of the Constitution of India against the order dated 15‑09‑2023 passed by the 21st Additional Judge, City Civil Court at Allikulam, Chennai (O.S. No.606 of 2020).
- Original suit (C.S. No.574 of 2013) sought declaration that the Memorandum of Understanding dated 13‑01‑2006 and the deed of family settlement dated 03‑04‑2006 were null and void, and that the deed of family settlement be set aside.
- The suit was transferred to the City Civil Court and renumbered O.S. No.606 of 2020.
- Petitioners argued the application to reject the plaint (filed under Order VII Rule 11 CPC) should have been allowed on the ground of no cause of action and limitation bar.
- The lower court dismissed the application, holding that limitation was a mixed question of law and fact, that the plaint disclosed a cause of action, and that the suit was not barred.
- Petitioners contended that the MoU and family settlement deed violated Section 53 of the Indian Trusts Act, 1882, were executed under undue influence after the death of the father on 27‑09‑2005, and that Section 10 of the Limitation Act should apply, rendering the suit non‑time‑barred.
- Respondents counter‑claimed that the suit property belonged to a family trust created by a deed of declaration of trust dated 14‑05‑1992, that the father was a permanent trustee and beneficiary, and that upon his death the plaintiffs became surviving beneficiaries with a 24% share.
- They argued the MoU of 13‑01‑2006 unlawfully removed the plaintiffs’ beneficial interest without court permission, and that the subsequent family settlement deed of 03‑04‑2006 (releasing 25% of the share) was unnecessary and also required court approval.
- Both parties relied on provisions of the Indian Trusts Act, 1882 and the Limitation Act, 1963.
Final Outcome
- The Madras High Court, after careful consideration, found no ground to interfere with the lower court’s order dated 15‑09‑2023.
- The civil revision petition is dismissed and the impugned order is sustained.
- The petitioner is free to raise the same ground before the City Civil Court, which must frame specific issues and decide on merits based on evidence.
- The Court directed the 21st Judge, City Civil Court, Chennai to dispose of O.S. No.606 of 2020 within nine months from receipt of this order.
- No costs were awarded; the connected CMP is also dismissed.
Topics: Legal Dispute, Trust Law, Civil Procedure