Authority: Supreme Court of India (Civil Appellate Jurisdiction)
Order Date: 17 November 2026
Case Overview
- Parties: Appellant – Meghalaya Power Generation Corporation Ltd. (MePGCL), a government undertaking; Respondents – Odimar Syiemsad and others (unsuccessful bidder).
- Background: On 04‑07‑2023 MePGCL issued a tender notice for construction of a multipurpose indoor stadium at Nongtrai Village, Mawsynram, East Khasi Hills, with an estimated cost of Rs 2,87,89,896/‑. Five technically qualified bidders submitted bids. Financial bids were opened on 08‑09‑2023; four bidders quoted Rs 2,87,89,896/‑ (joint lowest bidders) and were declared lowest bidders, while the unsuccessful bidder quoted Rs 2,87,89,897.34/‑ (Rs 1.34 higher) and was declared L2.
- Tender Committee Interaction: On 07‑02‑2024 the Tender Committee met with the lowest bidders. Three of those bidders withdrew their bids and consented to award the contract to the successful bidder (respondent no.2). A work order was issued to the successful bidder on 15‑02‑2024.
- Writ Petition: The unsuccessful bidder filed a writ petition seeking quashing of the work order. Single Judge of the High Court, in a judgment dated 07‑06‑2024, found that the lowest bidders had acted in collusion, quashed the work order and directed a fresh tender.
- High Court Appeal: Both MePGCL and the successful bidder filed intra‑court appeals. The Division Bench of the High Court, in a judgment dated 01‑09‑2025, held that there was no evidence of a cartel, that technical evaluation was proper, and that the award to the successful bidder was neither illegal nor wrongful. However, it observed that the unsuccessful bidder was deprived of a legitimate expectation of being called for negotiations and, relying on A.T. Brij Paul Singh & Bros. v. State of Gujarat, awarded compensation at 7.5% of the work value, quantifying it at Rs 21,59,242/‑.
- Supreme Court Submissions: MePGCL argued that the High Court erred in awarding compensation in a writ proceeding. The successful bidder supported this view. The unsuccessful bidder did not appear.
- Supreme Court Reasoning: The Court held that:
(i) The compensation direction contradicted the High Court’s own findings of no cartel, proper evaluation, no impropriety, and a lawful award.
(ii) The suggestion that all five bidders could have been asked to revise bids is merely a view on a better course, not a finding of illegality.
(iii) No infringement of the bidder’s right to fair consideration was found.
(iv) Even if a legitimate expectation existed, it does not give rise to damages in a writ petition.
(v) The High Court went beyond the relief sought (only quashing of the work order) by imposing monetary liability.
(vi) No foundation for a compensation claim was laid in the pleadings.
(vii) The A.T. Brij Paul Singh precedent relates to damages under Section 73 of the Indian Contract Act for wrongful rescission of a concluded contract; here no contract was awarded to the unsuccessful bidder, so loss of profit could not be assessed.
(viii) A writ court that finds the decision‑making process valid cannot simultaneously impose monetary liability on a Government Undertaking.
Final Outcome
- The Supreme Court quashed and set aside the portion of the High Court judgment directing payment of Rs 21,59,242 to the unsuccessful bidder.
- The remainder of the High Court judgment dated 01‑09‑2025 was upheld.
- The successful bidder may proceed under the contract awarded to it.
- The appeal was allowed; no order as to costs was made.
- Any pending applications, if any, stand disposed of.
Topics: Tender Procurement, Compensation Award, Judicial Review