Authority: Supreme Court of India
Order Date: 18-11-2026
Case Overview
- Petitioner: Municipal Corporation, Amritsar
- Respondents: Meera Sharma & Ors.
- Origin: Petition for Special Leave to Appeal (C) No. 35500/2026 arising from the impugned final judgment and order dated 11‑08‑2026 in LPA No. 284/2026 passed by the High Court of Punjab & Haryana at Chandigarh.
- Multiple SLPs: The order addresses a series of SLP(C) numbers (e.g., 35500/2026, 36226/2026, 36332/2026, … up to 39366/2026) and also references SLP(C) Nos. 31436/2026, 34746/2026, etc.
- Background: In C.W.P. No. 9942/2005, a Single Judge dated 15‑01‑2026 directed the respondents to regularise the services of the first respondent as Assistant Pump Operator within six weeks, deeming him regularised if no order was passed. The petitioner challenged this order via a Letter Patent Appeal (LPA) which was decided on 10‑07‑2026 in Municipal Council Malerkotla.
- Key Legal Points Discussed:
- Whether the decision dated 10‑07‑2026, which directed pension payment under a discontinued scheme, applies.
- Qualification of the first respondent for the post of Assistant Pump Operator.
- Eligibility for pension under the Old Pension Scheme (GPF) discontinued in 2004.
Court Observations & Reasoning
- The Court noted the undisputed fact that the first respondent has been working with the petitioner since 1993 (and in another petition since 1996‑1997).
- It recognised the limited issue of regularisation and pension eligibility.
- While acknowledging the earlier judgment, the Court clarified that the present order is confined to the facts of this case and shall not set a precedent.
Directions & Orders
1. Notice Issuance: Issue notice to all respondents in the listed SLPs.
2. Personal Service: Petitioner to serve personal notice to respondents by Registered Post with Acknowledgment Due (RPAD) and file proof within 10 days.
3. Tagging: Tag the matters with SLP (C) No. 7447/2024.
4. Waiver of Service: For SLP(C) Nos. 31436/2026, 34746/2026, 34097/2026, 34876/2026, 33988/2026, and 37502/2026, service of notice is waived as Advocate‑on‑Record Abhimanyu Tewari accepted notice on behalf of the respondents.
5. Time for Reply: A week is granted to the learned counsel for the respondents to file a reply.
6. Listing: All matters listed for hearing on 02‑12‑2026.
7. Regularisation Order (SLP(C) No. 36131/2026):
- Services of the first respondent are regularised as Assistant Pump Operator effective 01‑01‑2012.
- The respondent will be on probation for three years, deemed completed on 31‑12‑2015.
- Petitioner directed to pay arrears arising from this regularisation.
- Respondent not entitled to pension under the Old Pension Scheme (GPF) discontinued in 2004.
8. Stay of Impugned Judgments (SLP(C) No. 38229/2026): Stay limited to determining eligibility of pensionary benefits; petitioner must undertake regularisation as directed.
9. Other SLPs (e.g., 36288/2026, 36675‑36676/2026, 37040‑37041/2026, 37137/2026): Similar notice issuance, service directions, and listing for 02‑12‑2026.
10. Disposition: The Special Leave Petition(s) are disposed of as indicated; pending applications, if any, stand disposed.
Final Outcome
- The Court confirmed regularisation of the first respondent as Assistant Pump Operator from 01‑01‑2012, with probation deemed completed on 31‑12‑2015, ordered payment of arrears, denied pension under the Old Pension Scheme, and stayed the impugned judgments only to the extent of pension eligibility. All listed SLPs are scheduled for further hearing on 02‑12‑2026.
Topics: Court Proceedings, Employment Regularisation