Authority: High Court of Judicature at Madras
Order Date: 20.11.2026
Case Overview
- Parties: Appellant – M/s N.C. Arya Snuff & Cigar Co. (partnership firm represented by partner K.R. Ragurramun). Respondents – M/s Nico Quality Products (partner K.C. Vijay and others), along with individual defendants V. Shankar Amarnath, V. Sreenivasan, etc. The matter arose from three Original Side Appeals (OSA(CAD) Nos. 84, 90 and 96 of 2025) filed under Section 13 of the Commercial Courts Act, 2015, seeking to set aside the common judgment and decree dated 24.01.2025 passed by the learned Single Judge in CS Nos. 605 (2013), 882 (2013) and 587 (2015).
- Background: The plaintiff, a long‑standing manufacturer of snuff, cigars, agarbathis and scented sticks, operated as a family partnership (partners S. Chandrasekaran, S. Thara and later Anuradha). After Anuradha assumed control, the business suffered financial distress. Anuradha retired on 30.06.2012, and the remaining partners sought to settle creditors. They purportedly executed an authorisation letter dated 27.10.2011 (Ex.P2) and a deed of assignment dated 15.12.2011 (Ex.P3) transferring ten Class‑34 trademarks (Nos. 454103, 454106, 454109, 592763, 180448, 180449, 559308, 178484, 179074, 194656) to M/s Nico Quality Products for a cash consideration of Rs. 75 Lakhs.
- Dispute: The plaintiff challenged the authenticity of the authorisation letter and the assignment deed, alleging forgery, fabrication, non‑registration within six months under Section 42 of the Trade Marks Act, and sought permanent injunctions against infringement and passing‑off. The respondent contended that the documents were genuine, the consideration was paid, and the assignment included goodwill, rendering the six‑month registration requirement inapplicable.
- Evidence: The court examined extensive documentary evidence: Ex.P2 (authorisation letter), Ex.P3 (assignment deed), Ex.P4 (letter dated 20.12.2011 acknowledging receipt of Rs. 75 Lakhs), Ex.P20 (letter dated 21.06.2012 requesting an additional Rs. 20 Lakhs and providing a blank cheque), Ex.P23‑P25 (bank correspondence and receipt of Rs. 16 Lakhs payment), Ex.P24 (Axis Bank letter confirming Vijay as representative), Ex.P26‑P27 (non‑renewal of firm registration and cancellation of sales‑tax registration), Ex.P31 (trademark registration in the respondent’s name dated 20.09.2021), and various affidavits and partnership agreements. The court noted that the signatures of both partners were present on Ex.P2, with D.W.2 (Thara) admitting her signature, and that the plaintiff never denied Ex.P4, Ex.P20‑P27.
- Issues Framed by Single Judge: (i) Authenticity of authorisation letter; (ii) Validity of assignment deed; (iii) Infringement and passing‑off by respondent; (iv) Whether goodwill was transferred; (v) Reliefs claimed.
Final Outcome
- The Court held that the authorisation letter (Ex.P2) and the assignment deed (Ex.P3) were genuine and not forged. The deed transferred the ten trademarks with all benefits and goodwill in Class 34 for exclusive use in India and abroad.
- Consequently, the plaintiff’s claims of infringement and passing‑off were rejected; the respondent was entitled to a permanent injunction against the plaintiff.
- The assignment deed was deemed valid in law, and the six‑month registration requirement under Section 42 was inapplicable because the assignment included goodwill.
- All three Original Side Appeals (OSA(CAD) Nos. 84, 90, 96 of 2025) were dismissed, confirming the learned Single Judge’s judgment and decree.
- No costs were awarded to either party, and all connected miscellaneous petitions were closed.
Topics: Trademark Assignment, Permanent Injunction