Authority: High Court of Meghalaya at Shillong
Order Date: 20.11.2026
Case Overview
- Parties: Applicant – Divisional Manager, National Insurance Co. Ltd, Shillong. Respondents – (1) Shri Shub Karan Singh Rathore (deceased) substituted by Smti Santosh Kawar, (2) Shri G.K. Mohan Camin, owner of oil tanker WB‑03A‑1791, (3) Md. Irfan Khan, driver of the same tanker, (4) Divisional Manager, The Oriental Insurance Company Ltd, Shillong, (5) Shri R.S. Bajoria. The case is recorded as MC(MACApp) No. 2 of 2026.
- Background: The Motor Accident Claim Tribunal (MACT), Shillong, delivered a judgment and award on 28.03.2025 in MAC Case No. 5 of 2010. National Insurance Co. Ltd filed an appeal against that award but did so 279 days after the MACT judgment, seeking condonation of delay.
- Grounds for Delay: The applicant argued that verification of the driver’s licence (Registration No. WB‑03A‑1791) took time; an RTI to the D.T.O. Nagaland on 17.09.2025 revealed that Licence No. 87364/MKG/PROFF in the name of Md. Irfan Khan did not exist. The applicant also cited counsel’s absence (04.11.2025‑19.02.2026) and the High Court’s winter vacation (18.12.2025‑26.01.2026) as reasons for the delay.
- Opposition: Respondent No. 1 (claimant’s substitute) raised no objection. Respondent No. 4 (Oriental Insurance) opposed, stating that the applicant had not shown sufficient cause and had exhibited lack of due diligence.
- Counsel Submissions:
- Applicant’s counsel (Mr. D.M. Rani) admitted the delay and presented the above explanations.
- Respondent No. 4’s counsel (Mr. S. Jindal) argued that the delay was not justified, noting that the RTI was filed six months after the MACT award and that the applicant had not pursued licence verification during the original claim proceedings (filed February 2010).
- The court noted that after the winter vacation the applicant still did not file the condonation petition until 01.04.2026, providing no cogent explanation.
- Legal Precedents Cited: Esha Bhattarcharjee v. Managing Committee of Raghunathpur Nafar Academy & Ors. (2013) 12 SCC 649, para 18; Basawaraj & Anr. v. Special Land Acquisition Officer (2013) 14 SCC 81, para 11; Maniben Devraj Shah v. Municipal Corporation of Brihan Mumbai (2012) 5 SCC 157, para 24, discussing “sufficient cause”.
Final Outcome
- The Court held that the applicant had not shown sufficient cause for the 279‑day delay, emphasizing lack of due diligence and unexplained filing after the court’s re‑opening.
- The petition for condonation of delay was dismissed as devoid of merit.
Topics: Condensation of Delay, Insurance Litigation