Case Overview
The appeal arose from the Corporate Insolvency Resolution Process (CIRP) of Nik-San Engineering Company Limited, initiated by Sterling Enamelled Wires Private Limited under Section 9 of the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016. The NCLT Mumbai Bench-IV admitted the application on 03.11.2022 and appointed Rakesh Kumar Tulsyan as Resolution Professional.
Vilas Transcore Limited (Appellant) had its resolution plan approved with 100% voting share by the Committee of Creditors (CoC) in the 11th meeting held on 25.08.2023, when Bank of Baroda was the sole member. A Letter of Intent was issued to Vilas Transcore on 26.09.2023, and they furnished a Performance Bank Guarantee of ₹1 crore. The Resolution Professional filed I.A. No. 4903/2023 seeking approval of this plan.
Subsequently, Varsha Engineers filed I.A. No. 4997/2023 seeking inclusion in the CoC, and Aesthetic Stampings & Laminations Limited along with Abhishek Naresh Choudhary (Respondent No. 3) filed I.A. No. 5507/2023 seeking reconsideration of their resolution plan. By order dated 06.12.2023, the NCLT directed inclusion of Varsha Engineers in the CoC and reconsideration of resolution plans. The CoC was reconstituted with Bank of Baroda (90.6% voting share) and Varsha Engineers (9.4% voting share).
In the 14th CoC meeting on 15.02.2024, the resolution plans were reconsidered without inviting Vilas Transcore. Respondent No. 3's plan was ultimately approved with 100% voting share, providing a total amount of ₹30,65,84,377/-, including ₹8,74,64,280/- against secured financial creditor claims of ₹15,09,94,786/-. The NCLT approved this plan by order dated 29.08.2024.
The Appellant challenged this approval, contending that the reconsideration process violated Regulation 12(3) of the CIRP Regulations (which preserves validity of decisions taken before subsequent inclusion of creditors) and Section 30(5) of the Code (right of resolution applicant to attend CoC meetings). The Appellant also filed a contempt case alleging implementation of the plan despite NCLAT's directions.
Final Outcome
The NCLAT set aside the NCLT's order dated 29.08.2024 approving Respondent No. 3's resolution plan. The Tribunal found that:
1. The reconsideration process violated Regulation 12(3) as the earlier approval of Vilas Transcore's plan should have been preserved
2. The Appellant was not invited to the 14th CoC meeting on 15.02.2024, violating Section 30(5) of the Code
3. The Resolution Professional's failure to file a reply in I.A. No. 4997/2023 led to incorrect assumptions by the NCLT
4. The same comparative information was presented to the reconstituted CoC, yet it reached a different conclusion without adequate reasoning
The NCLAT revived I.A. No. 4903/2023 (seeking approval of Vilas Transcore's plan) and directed the NCLT to take a final decision on its approval within one month. Company Appeal (AT) (Ins.) No. 1667 of 2024 was disposed of as infructuous, and Contempt Case (AT) No. 7 of 2025 was dismissed.
Topics: Insolvency Resolution, Committee of Creditors, Resolution Plan Approval