Authority: High Court of Uttarakhand at Nainital
Order Date: 20 November 2026
Case Overview
- Appellant: New India Assurance Company Ltd (insurance company) filed appeal under Section 173 of Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 against judgment and award dated 02 May 2012 of Motor Accident Claims Tribunal/Additional District Judge, Haridwar, in MACP No.09 of 2005 (Kishan Bahadur & others v. Mohd. Asgar Ali & others).
- Respondents: Kishan Bahadur (deceased’s husband) and three sons (Gajendra Prasad, Deepak Prasad, Ravindra Prasad) as claimants; also owner and driver of truck bearing registration No. D.I.G.-481 (Mohd. Asgar Ali) were parties in original claim.
- Accident: On 31 December 2004 at about 09:30 a.m., Smt. Madhumalti was struck by the truck while riding a bicycle near Jwalapur, Haridwar, resulting in her death.
- Claim: Claimants sought ₹10,00,000 compensation from owner, driver, and insurer. Tribunal awarded ₹3,78,000 (based on notional annual income ₹36,000, one‑fourth personal expenses, multiplier 14) with interest at 6% per annum from 24 July 2009.
- Insurance defence: New India Assurance argued that the insurance policy covering the vehicle had expired on 02 November 2004 and that the policy was obtained after the accident (proposal received at 02:00 p.m. on 31 Dec 2004), thus denying liability.
- Owner/driver defence: Asserted policy expressly commenced coverage from 00:00 hours on 31 Dec 2004, covering the accident.
Final Outcome
- The Court held that the policy’s commencement clause (00:00 on 31‑12‑2004) makes the insurer liable for the accident occurring at 09:30 the same day.
- The appeal is dismissed; the Tribunal’s judgment and award of ₹3,78,000 with interest is affirmed.
- The insurer must deposit the statutory amount of ₹25,000 (if not already paid) and release the award amount with accrued interest to the claimants within eight weeks of the order.
- The Tribunal is directed to inform the claimants of the judgment.
Topics: Insurance Liability, Motor Accident Compensation