Authority: High Court at Calcutta (Appellate Side)
Order Date: 19 November 2026
Case Overview
- Parties: Appellants – Kalpana Murmu & Ors.; Respondents – Oriental Insurance Co. Ltd. & Anr.
- Appeal No.: FMA‑1158 of 2013, arising from MAC Case No. 537/2010 decided by the Additional District Judge, Fast Track 1st Court, Berhampur, Murshidabad on 29 March 2012.
- Background: On 01‑01‑2010, Sunil Murmu (deceased) and other labourers were riding a tractor (registration WB‑57/3707) carrying paddy sticks. The tractor struck an overhead electric line, causing a fire; Sunil sustained severe burns and died on 02‑01‑2010 at Berhampore N.G. Hospital.
- Lower Court Findings: The trial judge dismissed the claim, holding the accident did not arise from the use of a motor vehicle and that the trailer was not a goods carriage; the insurer and vehicle owner were not made parties.
- Appellants’ Contentions: The death was due to negligent driving of the insured tractor; the owner (father) was not impleaded; no evidence of policy violation concerning carriage of different goods.
- Legal Provisions Discussed: Section 163A of the Motor Vehicles Act 1988 (no‑fault liability), Section 164 (compensation amount), and relevant Supreme Court precedents (Royal Sundaram Alliance v. Hannamma, Ningamma v. United India Insurance, etc.).
- Court’s Reasoning: Established that the accident occurred due to use of the insured tractor; liability under Section 163A is not defeated by non‑impleading of trailer owner or lack of policy‑violation issue; cited Supreme Court observations that the tractor’s negligence is the root cause.
Final Outcome
- The judgment and award dated 29 March 2012 is set aside.
- Claimants are entitled to compensation of Rs 500,000 (Rs 5 lakh) as per the amended provision of Section 164.
- Oriental Insurance Co. Ltd. must deposit Rs 5 lakh with interest at 6% per annum from the date of filing the claim until payment.
- Payment to be made within eight weeks of communication of this order.
- The compensation may be withdrawn by the claimants in equal shares after completion of necessary formalities and payment of deficit court fees.
- An urgent photostat certified copy of the order shall be provided to parties upon compliance with requisite formalities.
Topics: Motor Vehicle Compensation, Insurance Liability