Authority: High Court at Calcutta, Constitutional Writ Jurisdiction (Appellate Side)

Order Date: 19 November 2026

Case Overview

  • Petitioner: Ajoy Deb Mandal, former Assistant Manager I/C and Deputy Manager I/C (2010‑2014) in the Magma Cell/Broker Business Cell, Kolkata of Oriental Insurance Company Limited (OICL), a public sector insurer.
  • Respondents: Oriental Insurance Company Limited (Respondent No.1) and its office bearers (Respondents Nos.2‑4).
  • Disciplinary proceedings were initiated under the Oriental Insurance Co. (Conduct, Discipline & Appeal) Rules, 2014 alleging that the petitioner, in collusion with unknown officials of DO‑5, OICL Kolkata, approved and issued more than 500 Motor TP stand‑alone policies under the Motor Miscellaneous head between January 2012 and 2014, thereby substituting higher‑premium commercial vehicle policies with lower‑premium Misc‑D policies. The alleged loss to OICL was approximately Rs 67 lakhs.
  • The Enquiry Officer’s report (dated 26 November 2019) found charges 2‑5 fully proved and charge 1 partially proved; the Disciplinary Authority treated charge 1 as fully proved and imposed a penalty of reduction in basic pay by three increments in the time scale (order dated 8 March 2021).
  • The petitioner appealed to the Appellate Authority (Respondent No.2) on 3 June 2021; the appeal was rejected on 20 December 2021 without detailed reasons.
  • Parallel criminal proceedings (CBI/ACB/S No. RC0102017A003) were instituted; the CBI filed a charge sheet on 28 September 2019, finding no criminality against the petitioner (only one other individual, Sri Tanmoy Ghosh, was implicated). The Special CBI Court dropped the criminal case on 21 April 2022.
  • The petitioner submitted multiple representations (4 June 2020, 11 June 2020, 13 December 2021, 23 February 2022) and a mercy petition on 13 March 2023, invoking the advice of the National Commission for Scheduled Castes.
  • Respondent No.3, on 30 August 2022, upheld the disciplinary order, stating no new material facts were found.
  • On 25 September 2023, Respondent No.2 reduced the penalty to reduction in basic pay by two increments, citing humanitarian grounds based on the petitioner’s Scheduled Caste status.
  • The petitioner challenged this reduction through WPA No.14467 of 2024, arguing lack of reasons, violation of natural justice, and that the CBI’s exoneration should nullify the disciplinary findings.
  • The respondents contended that disciplinary and criminal proceedings are distinct, that the penalty reduction on humanitarian grounds does not require detailed reasoning, and that the petitioner had accepted the disciplinary findings.
  • The Court examined precedents, including Karnataka Power Transmission Corp. Ltd. (Supra), affirming that an acquittal in criminal court does not preclude departmental action where evidence differs.

Final Outcome

  • The Court held there is no scope for interference with the order dated 25 September 2023 reducing the penalty to two increments; the disciplinary findings remain valid.
  • The mercy‑petition reduction on humanitarian grounds is an act of clemency, not a re‑adjudication of guilt, and therefore stands.
  • The writ petition (WPA No.14467/2024) is dismissed without costs; all pending applications are disposed, interim orders vacated, and parties directed to act on the server copies of the judgment.

Topics: Legal Judgment, Disciplinary Proceedings, Mercy Petition