Authority: High Court at Calcutta
Order Date: 20.11.2026
Case Overview
- Parties: Petitioner – Prasanta Kumar Pahari, Superintendent, West Bengal State Warehousing Corporation (Officer‑in‑Charge of RIDF godown, Gaighata, Debipur). Respondent – State of West Bengal.
- Proceedings: Application CRR 2747 of 2025 (Special Case No. 11 of 2021, Gaighata Police Station Case No. 918 dated 23.11.2019) filed under section 528 of the Bengal National Security Act (BNSS) seeking quashment of criminal proceedings under section 409 of the Indian Penal Code (IPC).
- Allegations: On 23.11.2019, while dispatching rice against four delivery orders (total 1,571.00 quintals), petitioner allegedly loaded an excess of 64 quintals (≈128 bags) onto a truck without government authority sanction. The excess loading was discovered during weighment; petitioner is said to have instructed unloading, but the complaint alleges illegal loading for personal gain.
- Legal Framework Discussed: Elements of offence under section 409 IPC – (1) accused is a public servant, (2) entrustment of property, (3) dishonest misappropriation. The court examined precedents (State vs Gujarat Vs Jaswant Lal Nathalal, State vs Orissa Vs Gansh Chandra Jeu, Bhajan Lal vs State of Haryana, etc.) on entrustment and misappropriation.
- Petitioner’s Arguments: Excess loading occurred during routine institutional dispatch; no personal custody or dishonest conversion; lack of seizure of registers or logs; no evidence of sale or monetary gain; absence of sanction under section 197 CrPC; prolonged prosecution amounts to abuse of process.
- State’s Arguments: Investigation collected sufficient material; offence not protected by section 197 as it is not a public‑work matter; 8 witnesses to be examined; disciplinary action (withholding two increments) dated 08.06.2022 and affirmed 29.09.2022 is under challenge (WPA 394 of 2023) and remains sub‑judice.
- Court’s Reasoning: While the defence materials cannot be entertained at the quashment stage, the prosecution’s case shows prima facie entrustment and possible dishonest use. The court emphasized that high‑court inherent power under section 482 CrPC/section 528 BNSS cannot be exercised to quash a proceeding where material exists indicating an offence. The court rejected the petition, noting that the trial must determine the factual issues.
Final Outcome
- The petition for quashment (CRR 2747 of 2025) is dismissed.
- The trial court is directed to expedite the trial and endeavour to conclude it within six months from the next hearing date.
- The observations are limited to the quashment application; the trial will address the merits of the criminal charge.
Topics: Court Decision, Criminal Breach of Trust, Procedural Quashment