Authority: Calcutta High Court (Constitutional Writ Jurisdiction)
Order Date: 20 November 2026
Case Overview
- Parties: Siddhi Vinayak Himghar (P) Ltd. & Ors. (petitioners) vs. Punjab National Bank & Anr. (respondent).
- Background: Petitioners, manufacturers of organic manure, had obtained credit facilities initially from Canara Bank (₹24 lakhs) later taken over and enhanced by United Bank of India to ₹50 lakhs. Subsequent acquisitions of NPA cold‑storage units increased exposure; they claimed stress due to demonetisation, potato‑market decline, COVID‑19, and RBI moratoriums.
- Procedural History:
- Show‑cause notice dated 21 Dec 2023 demanded explanation for classifying the loan as a “fraud account”.
- Petitioners requested the underlying forensic audit report (FAR); the bank did not comply.
- On 21 Mar 2024 the bank intimated that the account had been classified as a fraud account.
- Earlier litigation: WPA 9820 2021 (interim relief denied, appealed as MAT 643 2021, status‑quo order), OA 410 2022 before the Debts Recovery Tribunal, and a subsequent order on 5 Aug 2025 allowing WPA 9820 2021 (appealed as MAT 1887 2025, pending).
- Bank’s Position: The loan was classified as NPA per RBI Master Directions (2016) and FRMD Circular No. 70/2023. A forensic audit was conducted; the bank alleges the petitioners failed to cooperate. The bank claims extracts of the FAR were supplied with the show‑cause notice and that the procedure under its internal FRMD circular (Initiative Authority, Reviewing Authority, Final Authority) was duly followed.
- Petitioners’ Position: The full FAR was never provided; only extracts (if any) were given, depriving them of a genuine opportunity to contest the allegations. They argue the bank violated natural‑justice principles and RBI directions, and that the March 21 2024 communication was issued without a reasoned order.
- Legal Precedents Cited: Supreme Court decisions in State Bank of India v. Rajesh Agarwal (2023), State Bank of India v. Amit Iron Private Ltd. (2026 INSC 323), and Hemanta Kanoria v. Bank of India (2024 SCC OnLine Cal 1012). The court reiterated that borrowers must be given the entire forensic audit report, subject only to justified redaction for third‑party privacy.
Final Outcome
- The communication dated 21 Mar 2024 classifying the account as a fraud account is set aside.
- The show‑cause notice dated 21 Dec 2023 is revived.
- Punjab National Bank must furnish the complete forensic audit report to the petitioners, permitting redaction only where the bank records specific reasons relating to third‑party privacy.
- Upon receipt, petitioners will have a reasonable opportunity to submit written representations on the findings.
- The bank’s competent authority must then consider the representations and pass a fresh, reasoned order in accordance with RBI Directions.
- The court expresses no opinion on the merits of the alleged fraud, diversion, or criminal breach of trust; those matters remain for the bank’s internal adjudication and the Debt Recovery Tribunal.
- No order as to costs; urgent certified copy of the order may be supplied upon compliance with formalities.
Topics: Court Order, Banking Regulation, Natural Justice