Authority: High Court of Judicature at Madras

Order Date: 03 January 2018 (pronounced)

Reserved On: 16 November 2017

Case Overview

  • Petitioners: Union of India (Secretary, Ministry of Railways, Railway Board, New Delhi), General Manager Southern Railway, Chennai, Chief Personnel Officer Southern Railway, Chennai, Divisional Personnel Officer Southern Railway, Salem Division.
  • Respondents: Registrar, Central Administrative Tribunal (CAT), Madras Bench, Chennai; A. Shaik Dawood; M. Mohammed Ibrahim; T.S. Balarajan; K. Rajendran; S. Oliver Kamalakaran.
  • Prayer: Writ petition under Article 226 seeking a writ of certiorari to obtain all records of the first respondent in O.A. No.920 of 2009, including the order dated 04‑Oct‑2010, and to quash that order.
  • Background Facts:

1. Applicants (respondents 2‑6) were Loco Pilots (Goods) Grade‑II in Palghat Division, transferred to the newly created Salem Division on 01‑Nov‑2007 with salary scale Rs.5,000‑8,000.

2. The Divisional Personnel Officer, Salem, issued a provisional seniority list on 16‑Sep‑2008 placing the applicants at serial numbers 4‑8.

3. The Division announced 46 vacancies for Loco Pilot (Goods) Grade‑I (scale Rs.5,500‑9,000) with a selection method of viva voce; alert notice dated 02‑Jan‑2009 was issued to 25 Grade‑I pilots, followed by a second alert on 05‑Jan‑2009 to eligible Grade‑II pilots.

4. Following the 6th Pay Commission (VI CPC) recommendations, Grade‑II posts were merged into Grade‑I, creating a new Pay Band‑II (Rs.9,300‑34,800) with Grade Pay Rs.4,200; an additional allowance of Rs.500 was granted to Passenger Pilots.

5. Railway Board Circular dated 23‑Sep‑2008 prohibited further promotions except for “running categories” (Loco Pilots and Guards), where horizontal promotions would continue.

6. A subsequent clarificatory circular RBE/161/2009 dated 03‑Sep‑2009 altered the selection methodology; consequently, the alert notice of 02‑Jan‑2009 was cancelled by a letter dated 19‑Oct‑2009.

7. The Divisional Personnel Officer, Salem, issued Office Order No. SA/43/2009 on 30‑Oct‑2009 promoting 37 employees as Loco Pilot Passenger in the new Pay Band‑II (Rs.9,300‑34,800 + GP + Rs.4,200).

8. Before the 30‑Oct‑2009 list was published, the applicants filed O.A. No.920 of 2009 on 05‑Sep‑2009 seeking recasting of seniority and filling of Passenger Driver posts.

  • CAT Order: The Central Administrative Tribunal, Madras Bench, directed the Railway Administration to recast the seniority list of Loco Pilot (Goods) Grade‑I & II as of 31‑Dec‑2005 and, based on that list, to fill the Passenger Driver posts as done by South Central Railway.
  • Railway Administration’s Writ Petition: Challenged the CAT order and argued that the Railway Board circulars were superseded, that the merger of grades should halt promotions, and that the South Central Railway circulars dated 24‑Feb‑2009 and 17‑Mar‑2009 were invalid.
  • Court Proceedings: Counsel for petitioners (V. Radhakrishnan) and respondents (including V. Raghavachari) appeared; respondents 2 and 5 did not appear despite notice.
  • Court Observations:
  • The Railway Board circulars of 23‑Sep‑2008 and 03‑Sep‑2009 were valid and continued to apply to running staff.
  • The merger of Grade‑II into Grade‑I under the VI Pay Commission was correctly reflected in the revised seniority list.
  • The cut‑off date of 31‑Dec‑2005, as fixed by South Central Railway, was appropriate.
  • No infirmity or illegality was found in the CAT’s order; therefore, no interference was warranted.

Final Outcome

  • The writ petition is dismissed, confirming the CAT order dated 04‑Oct‑2010.
  • The connected miscellaneous petition is closed.
  • No costs are awarded.

Topics: Railway Promotions, Judicial Review