Authority: High Court at Calcutta (Constitutional Writ Jurisdiction), Justice Krishna Rao

Order Date: 16 November 2026

Case Overview

  • Parties: Petitioner – Rajia Engineering; Respondents – State of West Bengal and associated officials.
  • Nature of proceeding: Writ petition (W.P.A. No. 26288 of 2026) seeking a mandamus directing respondents 2‑4 to issue a work order for dredging/de‑silting of New Cossey River after a Letter of Acceptance (LOA) had been issued.
  • Background: The Department of Irrigation and Waterways (I&W), Government of West Bengal, invited an RFP for dredging works based on an expert survey. Rajia Engineering bid at the top (Serial No. 1) with a bid value of Rs 5,86,58,035/‑ and was issued an LOA on 15 March 2026.
  • Performance security: The petitioner submitted a performance security of Rs 29,33,035/‑ and an additional bank guarantee of Rs 1,17,32,139/‑ on 17 March 2026.
  • Petitioner’s claim: Despite the LOA and security deposits, the respondents failed to issue the work order, preventing the petitioner from commencing the 18‑month contract.
  • State’s explanation: The I&W Department, after consulting the Finance Department, decided to replace the existing “Volume Sharing Method” with a “Revenue Sharing Method” for flood‑management dredging. A letter dated 9 June 2026 communicated this policy shift. A subsequent order dated 3 September 2026 directed that work orders be withheld and that the 59 ongoing contracts under the Volume Sharing Method be cancelled.
  • Policy rationale: The Revenue Sharing Method eliminates the need for a government stackyard, reduces pilferage risk, and is projected to generate higher revenue than the Volume Sharing Method, which the State deemed a loss to the exchequer.
  • Legal precedents cited: The petitioner relied on Mihan India Ltd. v. GMR Airports Ltd. (2022) 19 SCC 69 and Subodh Kumar Singh Rathour v. CEO (2024) 15 SCC 461, arguing that issuance of LOA and acceptance of security created a concluded contract. The State relied on Subodh Kumar (2024) to justify policy‑driven alteration of contracts in the public interest.

Final Outcome

  • The Court held that the respondents’ decision to adopt the Revenue Sharing Method after issuance of the LOA constitutes a policy change, not an arbitrary refusal to issue a work order.
  • Consequently, the Court declined to compel issuance of a work order to Rajia Engineering.
  • The Court directed the State to refund the performance security of Rs 29,33,035/‑ and the additional bank guarantee of Rs 1,17,32,139/‑ to the petitioner within one month from receipt of the order, with interest at 12% per annum calculated from 17 March 2026 until payment.
  • The petition was disposed of.

Topics: Legal, Public Policy, Infrastructure