Authority: High Court at Calcutta, Civil Appellate Jurisdiction

Order Date: 19 November 2026

Case Overview

  • Parties: Appellant – M/s. S N Chatterjee and Company; Respondents – State of West Bengal & others.
  • Nature of proceedings: Intra‑Court appeal (FMA No. 1649 of 2025) against an order dated 24 April 2024 issued by the Deputy Commissioner of State Tax, Durgapur Charge, which treated the adjudication order as a show‑cause notice.
  • Background: The appellant supplied “Goods Transport Agency Services” (SAC 9967) to Eastern Coalfields Limited (ECL) during FY 2018‑19. GST on these services is payable by the recipient under reverse charge at 5%.
  • The Assistant Commissioner issued a notice (Form GST ASMT‑10) on 6 Oct 2023 alleging excess Input Tax Credit and wrong GST rate, leading to a demand of Rs 2,94,26,791.67 each for CGST and SGST under Section 73(5).
  • A show‑cause notice (Form GST DRC‑01) was issued on 26 Dec 2023, requiring reply by 30 Jan 2024. The appellant replied, asserting no excess ITC and that tax had been paid.
  • On 18 Apr 2024, the appellant reversed an excess ITC claim of Rs 93,731 each (including interest). On 24 Apr 2024, the Deputy Commissioner issued an adjudication order (GST DRC‑07) demanding Rs 3,03,88,943 each for CGST and SGST, exceeding the earlier notice amount.
  • The appellant filed a writ petition seeking declaration of the nature of the service, quashing of the show‑cause notice and the adjudication order.
  • The Learned Single Judge directed that the adjudication order be treated as a show‑cause notice, fixing a response period.

Final Outcome

  • The Division Bench (Justices Rajarshi Bharadwaj and Sudip Deb) set aside the Single Judge’s direction, holding that an adjudication order cannot be treated as a show‑cause notice.
  • The Bench held that Section 75(7) of the CGST Act expressly prohibits a demand in the adjudication order from exceeding the amount specified in the show‑cause notice; the order’s demand of Rs 3,03,88,943 each for CGST and SGST was therefore unlawful.
  • Consequently, the adjudication order dated 24 April 2024 is set aside on the ground of excess demand. No opinion was expressed on the merits of the underlying tax liability.
  • The show‑cause notice remains valid; the respondents may proceed further in accordance with law, subject to statutory limitations.
  • No costs were awarded; parties may obtain certified copies upon compliance with formalities.

Topics: GST, Tax Law