Authority: High Court at Calcutta, Commercial Appellate Division (Original Side)
Order Date: 20 November 2026
Case Overview
- Parties: Appellant Saurabh Gupta (operating as sole proprietor "Gupta Infotech") vs. Respondent No. 1 Royal Sundaram General Insurance Company Limited and Respondent No. 2 an unnamed bank.
- Background: Gupta Infotech manufactured compact fluorescent lamps. The business insured its plant, machinery, stock‑in‑process, raw materials, finished goods and customs‑duty‑paid goods with Royal Sundaram in 2013. The policy (No. YB00013052000102) was renewed for the period 04‑09‑2015 to 03‑09‑2016, with a sum insured of Rs 14,50,00,000 and a premium of Rs 1,93,285.
- Incident: On 08‑06‑2016 at about 10:20 hrs, a fire broke out at the appellant’s office in the SDF (G) Building, SEZ, West Bengal, destroying the entire stock, raw materials and finished goods. The loss was reported to Ramnagar Police Station, Falta.
- Claim: Gupta assessed the loss at Rs 10,74,79,736 and lodged claim No. YB1040 with the insurer. The insurer’s surveyors assessed the loss at Rs 1,94,46,960 (survey reports dated 12‑05‑2017). The appellant’s own auditor also assessed the loss at Rs 10,74,79,736.
- Settlement Attempt: On 20‑06‑2017 the insurer sent a draft settlement agreement proposing payment of Rs 1,94,46,960. The appellant travelled to the insurer’s Chennai office, where he alleges he was “practically forced and induced” to sign the agreement on 23‑06‑2017, with an assurance that any balance would be dealt with favourably.
- Payment: The insurer transferred Rs 1,94,46,960 to the appellant’s account held with the bank (Respondent No. 2). The bank subsequently adjusted the amount against the appellant’s credit facility.
- Litigation: The appellant filed a suit seeking declaration, injunction, recovery of the full loss and other reliefs, alleging force, undue influence and misrepresentation. The insurer and the bank filed written statements denying the allegations.
- Lower Court: The Single Judge framed 13 issues; several were decided in favour of the appellant (jurisdiction, validity of policy, cause of fire, principal‑agent relationship). However, the judge concluded the appellant failed to prove that the settlement agreement was obtained by force or undue influence and dismissed the suit.
- Appeal Arguments: The appellant contended that the surveyor’s reports were biased, the settlement amount was lower than the actual loss, and that the agreement was voidable due to coercion. He relied on National Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Boghara Polyfab Pvt. Ltd. (2009) 1 SCC 267. The insurer argued the settlement was voluntarily executed after the appellant had knowledge of the assessed amount and that no representative was identified to substantiate the coercion claim.
- Bank’s Position: The bank admitted receipt of the settlement amount and its adjustment against the credit facility, stating it acted as the insurer’s agent under Section 230 of the Contract Act, 1872 and could not be jointly liable.
Final Outcome
- The appellate bench held that the appellant did not produce any oral or documentary evidence of force, undue influence, fraud or misrepresentation.
- The settlement agreement, signed in the presence of two witnesses, was deemed valid and binding.
- The appellant’s challenge to the surveyor’s valuation was deemed moot as the dispute was settled by the written agreement.
- The appeal was dismissed with costs; the connected application, if any, was disposed of, and the interim order was vacated.
- The order was certified and to be supplied to the parties upon undertaking.
Topics: Insurance Settlement, Contract Law