Authority: Supreme Court of India
Order Date: 06-11-2026
Case Overview
- Petitioner‑in‑person: Ms. Liz Mathew (Amicus Curiae) filed a Suo Moto writ petition (Civil) No(s).8/2026 seeking protection of trees and green cover in the Taj Trapezium Zone (TTZ).
- Applicants:
1. Administrative Commandant, Station Headquarters, Mathura Cantt., on behalf of Headquarters, 99 Artillery Brigade (seeking permission to fell 60 trees for Phase‑I of the Key Location Plan at Mathura Military Station).
2. Rajasthan State Road Development and Construction Corporation Limited (RSDRC) – seeking to fell 401 trees for widening/strengthening of the BOT Road Bharatpur‑Bayana‑Gangapur‑Bhadoti (KM 7/0 to 33/055).
3. Executive Engineer, Construction Division No. 2, Public Works Department, Firozabad (seeking permission to fell 739 trees for 4‑lane widening of State Highway 31, Tundla‑Awagarh Road).
4. POWERGRID Ghiror Transmission Ltd (PGTL) – mentioned for moving an application under CEC Reports Nos. 30 and 31.
- Amicus Curiae: Ms. Liz Mathew submitted self‑explanatory notes on both the Mathura and Rajasthan applications, recommending strict compliance with plantation and penalty conditions.
- Court Composition: Hon’ble Chief Justice, Hon’ble Justice Joymalya Bagchi, Hon’ble Justice V. Mohana.
- Procedural History: Multiple Inter‑Application (IA) numbers filed between 2024‑2026; matters referred to the Central Empowered Committee (CEC) for technical/environmental assessment; CEC reports issued on 20‑02‑2026, 30‑10‑2026, 02‑11‑2026, etc.; compliance inspections conducted on 23‑09‑2026 (Mathura) and 27‑08‑2026 (Rajasthan).
Findings & Directions
Mathura Military Station (IA Nos. 40499, 30884, 40488 of 2025)
- CEC Report No. 6 of 2026 recommended felling 44 trees (instead of 60) subject to conditions:
- Compensatory plantation of minimum 550 saplings within the applicant’s campus, to be maintained for five years; KML file to be shared with CEC.
- Additional plantation of 1,000 saplings of specified native species (300 Ficus spp., 500 mixed indigenous species, 200 pollinator‑friendly species) also to be maintained for five years.
- No felling permitted until the above plantations are verified by the Forest Department.
- Penalty of Rs 1,00,000 per tree for any unauthorized felling or damage.
- IA No. 30884 disposed on 03‑09‑2026 after applicant’s statement of compliance; CEC independently verified on 23‑09‑2026 that all 1,550 saplings were alive, healthy, and protected.
- Court, relying on CEC verification and Amicus note, granted permission to fell 44 trees and ordered the compliance report to be uploaded on the MIS module.
Rajasthan Road Widening (IA Nos. 295707, 295719, 295717 of 2024)
- Original request: 401 trees; CEC Report No. 64 of 2025 recommended 236 trees (215 green, 21 dry).
- Applicant later sought 335 trees due to design change (paved shoulders increased to 100 cm). CEC Report No. 34 of 2026 (dated 02‑11‑2026) recommended felling 329 trees (308 green, 21 dry) after saving 6 trees.
- Conditions imposed (paragraph 9 of Report No. 34):
1. Compensatory plantation of 4,180 indigenous saplings in Village Katariyapur, District Bharatpur, to be funded by the applicant.
2. The 4.5 ha plantation area to be notified as Protected Forest by the State Government within six months.
3. Secure the plantation site with a six‑foot chain‑link fence on a two‑foot concrete wall.
4. Provide watering and ten‑year maintenance for the saplings.
5. Deposit required funds in an interest‑bearing bank account with the Divisional Forest Officer before any felling permission.
6. Post‑construction, both road sides to be planted with tall saplings of a long list of indigenous species (Ficus religiosa, Holoptelea integrifolia, etc.) at 5 m spacing, protected by brick/iron guards; costs to be borne by the applicant.
7. Forest Department to identify missing trees and report to CEC.
8. Penalty of Rs 1,00,000 per tree for any additional or accidental felling.
9. Applicant to comply with directions of the Court’s order dated 03‑09‑2026 and file a compliance affidavit.
- Amicus Curiae noted that compensatory afforestation had not yet been carried out; applicant claimed Rs 1,07,33,630 already deposited and land identified.
- Court directed the Rajasthan Forest Department to immediately commence afforestation, inform CEC upon completion, and thereafter grant permission for the 329 trees. All actions to be completed within two months.
Firozabad Public Works Department (IA No. 292695 of 2026)
- Application seeks permission to fell 739 trees for 4‑lane widening of State Highway 31 (Tundla‑Awagarh Road). Road width claimed to be 14.4 m (actual) versus 7 m (existing).
- Project involves diversion of 8.7335 ha of protected forest land.
- Forest clearance proposal submitted on PARVESH portal on 24‑04‑2026, recommended by Divisional Director, Social Forestry Division, Firozabad on 20‑06‑2026, pending further authority consideration.
- Court directed CEC to submit a self‑explanatory report‑cum‑recommendation covering the status of approval under the Van (Sanrakshan Evam Samvardhan) Adhiniyam, 1980 and the road width.
POWERGRID Ghiror Transmission Ltd (CEC Reports Nos. 30 & 31 of 2026)
- Court granted permission for PGTL to move an appropriate application along with its undertaking, referencing CEC recommendations for applications Nos. 1679 and 1686 of 2026.
- Registry instructed to list PGTL applications, as well as those of Railways and Ministry of Defence, on 19‑11‑2026 and to share copies with the Amicus Curiae (amicusttz@gmail.com).
Final Outcome
- Mathura Military Station: Permission granted to fell 44 trees after verification of 1,550 saplings; penalty of Rs 1 lakh per unauthorized tree; compliance report to be uploaded on MIS.
- Rajasthan Road Project: Permission to fell 329 trees contingent upon completion of 4,180‑tree compensatory afforestation, protected‑forest notification, fencing, funding deposit, and ten‑year maintenance; penalty of Rs 1 lakh per extra tree.
- Firozabad Highway Project: CEC to report on forest‑clearance status before any permission is considered.
- POWERGRID Ghiror Transmission Ltd: Allowed to proceed with its application as per CEC recommendations; procedural listings mandated.
- All parties directed to adhere strictly to the conditions, file compliance affidavits, and ensure that the MIS module reflects the CEC compliance reports.
Topics: Tree Felling Permission, Compensatory Afforestation, Environmental Compliance