Authority: Supreme Court of India, Civil Appellate Jurisdiction
Order Date: 18 November 2026
Case Overview
- Parties: Appellants – the estate of the late Bharat Bhushan Jain (through LRS) and others; Respondent – M/s Goodyear India Ltd.
- Subject: Long‑standing landlord‑tenant dispute concerning premises No. XI/4239‑A/2 (Plot No. 3A), 1 Ansari Road, Daryaganj, New Delhi, owned by the appellants and let to Goodyear.
- Timeline: Original suit filed in 1990 seeking possession and damages for use at Rs 1,47,500 per month (Rs 4,916.67 per day) from 02‑01‑1990, with 15% interest. Trial Court decree for possession dated 22‑12‑1998; possession decree became final in 2001 after dismissal of respondent’s revision and Supreme Court’s dismissal of SLP.
- Mesne profit proceedings: Under Order XX Rule 12 CPC, the trial court determined mesne profits at Rs 22 per sq ft per month for ground floor and Rs 11 per sq ft per month for mezzanine, with 15% interest. The First Appellate Court set aside this award, finding it speculative and not supported by evidence, and ordered a fresh determination based on the admitted rent rate.
- High Court (11‑08‑2011) considered a material admission by respondent’s witness (P.V. Ramani) that prevailing local rent ranged between Rs 5 and Rs 8 per sq ft per month. It fixed mesne profits at Rs 7 per sq ft per month for ground floor and Rs 5 per sq ft per month for mezzanine for the periods 02‑01‑1990 to 30‑03‑2001 and 02‑01‑1990 to 30‑04‑1999 respectively. It directed simple interest at 7.5% per annum from the month each mesne profit became due, reducible to 6% per annum if payment was made within two months.
- The present appeals before this Court challenge the High Court’s determination of mesne profits and interest.
Final Outcome
- The Supreme Court, after reviewing the record, finds the High Court’s assessment of mesne profits (Rs 7/‑sq ft ground, Rs 5/‑sq ft mezzanine) to be a balanced and evidence‑based determination, not arbitrary or speculative.
- The Court also upholds the interest award of simple interest at 7.5% per annum, with the concession of 6% per annum for prompt payment, as appropriate.
- No legal error is identified in the High Court’s judgment; the appeals are therefore dismissed.
- The Court emphasizes the need for finality, noting the litigation has spanned more than three decades.
Topics: Landlord‑Tenant Dispute, Mesne Profits