Authority: Appellate Authority under RTI Act, Securities and Exchange Board of India

Order Date: November 17, 2026

Case Overview

The appeal was filed by Heera Lal Khatri against the CPIO, SEBI, Mumbai regarding an RTI application dated September 14, 2026 concerning Cinema Capital Venture Fund Scheme-I (CCVF) and SEBI's final order dated April 30, 2025. The appellant sought multiple documents and information related to valuation reports, NAV calculation, investor exit processes, correspondence between SEBI and CCVF, and proceedings before the Securities Appellate Tribunal (SAT).

SEBI had provided partial information: for query 1 (valuation reports of Mr. Vijay Kumar Puri and ValAd Advisors), they provided copies as Annexures 1-8; for query 7 (Action Taken Report dated August 19, 2026), they provided copy as Annexure 9.

For queries 2, 3, 4, 9, 11, and 14 (supplementary valuation reports, NAV working papers, investor notice, CA-certified reports, and exit status for specific folios), SEBI stated the information was not available with them. The authority upheld this response citing Supreme Court precedent that RTI Act doesn't require public authorities to collect non-available information.

For queries 6, 8, and 10 (correspondence between SEBI-CCVF, subsequent action taken reports, and investor exit statistics), SEBI denied information under Section 8(1)(h) of RTI Act stating the matter is pending before SAT and disclosure would impede prosecution. For query 10, they additionally invoked Section 8(1)(j) regarding personal information privacy.

For queries 12 and 13 (SAT orders and interim orders affecting SEBI's directions), SEBI stated the information is available on SAT's website. The authority upheld this response citing precedent that information available in public domain need not be provided under RTI.

Final Outcome

The Appellate Authority found SEBI's invocation of Section 8(1)(h) for queries 6, 8, and 10 insufficiently justified and remanded these three queries back to the respondent for de novo consideration. SEBI must provide an appropriate response to the appellant within 15 working days from receipt of this order. The appeal was disposed of accordingly.

Topics: RTI Appeal, Venture Fund Valuation