Authority: Calcutta High Court
Order Date: November 20, 2026
Case Overview
- Parties: Appellant Iftekhar Alam vs. Respondent M/s. K. N. Paul (originally a partnership firm that later became a sole proprietorship).
- The appellant filed a Second Appeal (SA No. 103 of 2025) against a judgment of affirmance that upheld an eviction suit on the ground that the appellant was a licensee of the suit premises.
- The original plaint alleged that M/s. K. N. Paul inducted the appellant as a licensee. The plaint was later amended to state that the partnership had become a sole proprietorship due to retirement and death of some partners, leaving a single surviving partner.
- Simultaneously, the appellant obtained a declaratory suit decree declaring it a licensee of the premises and granting a permanent injunction restraining the respondent from disturbing possession "without due course of law".
- The appellant argued that the declaratory suit judgment should operate as res judicata in the eviction suit and that the two judgments were contradictory.
- The trial court, in the eviction suit, observed that a mere change in the constitution of the firm does not affect its relationship with the licensee; the entity remained the same for the purpose of the licence.
- Both suits held that the appellant was a licensee of the suit property.
- The question of whether the conversion affected the appellant's status as lessee under the Howrah Improvement Trust was not raised before the courts.
- The appellate court concurred with the lower courts that the conversion to a sole proprietorship did not alter the appellant's licensee status, as the essential character and jural relationship remained unchanged.
- The court found no contradiction between the declaratory suit injunction and the eviction decree; both were based on the appellant’s licensee status.
Final Outcome
- The Second Appeal (SA No. 103 of 2025) is dismissed under Order XLI Rule 11 of the Code of Civil Procedure.
- Consequently, the Cross‑Appeal (CAN 1 of 2025) is also dismissed.
- No order as to costs was made.
- Parties may obtain urgent certified copies of the order upon compliance with formalities.
Topics: Property Law, Licensee Rights