Authority: High Court of Karnataka, Bengaluru
Order Date: 20 November 2026
Case Overview
- Parties: Petitioners – Dr. Rajasekar Y L, Dr. Archana Singh, Dr. Shailesh G M and Shekar Eye Hospital (a unit of Varasiddhi Hospitals); Respondents – State of Karnataka (represented by SHO, Jayaprakash Nagar Police Station) and complainant Sadiya Mohammed (wife of Faizan Ahmed).
- Nature of Proceeding: Criminal petition under Section 482 of the CrPC seeking to set aside the order dated 10‑07‑2019 passed by the XLIV Additional Chief Metropolitan Magistrate, Bengaluru, which directed registration of FIR No.141/2019 for alleged medical negligence (IPC Sec 338) arising from ICL implantation procedures performed between August 2017 and April 2018.
- Background Facts: The complainant underwent Implantable Contact Lens (ICL) implantation in both eyes at Shekar Eye Hospital in August 2017. She subsequently experienced severe discomfort, elevated intra‑ocular pressure (IOP), secondary glaucoma, and ultimately 100 % blindness certified by multiple hospitals. She paid approximately Rs 8 lakhs for treatments and filed a private complaint on 03‑07‑2019 after earlier complaints to the Karnataka Medical Council (KMC) and the police. The magistrate ordered the police to investigate and register an FIR on 06‑08‑2019.
- Allegations: Petitioners were accused of rash/negligent ICL implantation, failure to warn of risks, inadequate post‑operative care, and causing irreversible loss of vision. The complainant claimed damages of about Rs 8 lakhs.
- Procedural Observations by the Court:
- Two‑year delay in filing the private complaint was highlighted but not deemed fatal.
- The private complaint lacked a prima‑facie expert medical opinion, a requirement articulated in the Supreme Court’s Jacob Mathew judgment.
- No independent government medical opinion was obtained by the investigating officer, contrary to the safeguards prescribed in Jacob Mathew, Martin F D’Souza and ASV Narayan Rao.
- The Karnataka Medical Council, after a full inquiry, had dismissed the negligence allegation on 03‑05‑2025, indicating no material negligence.
- Legal Reasoning: Citing Jacob Mathew (2005), Martin F D’Souza (2009), ASV Narayan Rao (2013), Dr. Shyamala Bai (2023) and other precedents, the Court held that criminal medical negligence requires gross negligence and a prior expert opinion. The absence of such opinion and the KMC’s dismissal rendered the FIR registration an abuse of process.
Final Outcome
The Court quashed the order dated 10 July 2019, the registration of FIR No.141/2019, and all subsequent proceedings against the petitioners, thereby relieving them of any criminal liability.
Topics: Medical Negligence, Criminal Procedure