Authority: High Court at Calcutta, Criminal Revisionary Jurisdiction (Appellate Side)

Order Date: 19.11.2026

Case Overview

  • Parties: Petitioners – Simoco Telecommunication (South Asia) Ltd (company incorporated under Companies Act 1956) and its employees (Managing Director, General Manager – Logistics, Officer‑in‑Charge – Purchase). Opposite Party No. 2 – supplier of imported mobile phones and accessories.
  • Nature of proceedings: Criminal appeal against conviction under Section 138 (and Section 141) of the Negotiable Instruments Act (NI Act) for dishonour of post‑dated cheques.
  • Background: Between 2006‑2009 the petitioner company purchased mobile sets from the opposite party, issuing post‑dated cheques. Seven cheques totalling Rs 36,12,174 were issued for full settlement. The opposite party issued a legal notice on 24.07.2008 alleging dishonour and demanded Rs 36,13,174, leading to Complaint No. 23410 of 2008.
  • Settlement: On 02.10.2008 the parties entered a bilateral settlement agreement; petitioner issued nine new cheques covering the aggregate sum of Rs 36,13,174. The opposite party was to return the original cheques and seek closure of the complaint.
  • Payments claimed by petitioners: (a) Rs 30,73,550 by RTGS on 14.11.2008; (b) Rs 4,00,000 by RTGS on 04.12.2008; (c) acknowledgement of these amounts by opposite party; (d) an outstanding Rs 1,39,624 claimed as inadvertent omission.
  • Lower courts’ findings: Trial Magistrate treated the settlement agreement as unilateral (deemed perverse by petitioners). Both the Metropolitan Magistrate (08.11.2019) and the Sessions Court (10.08.2023) affirmed conviction, relying on presumption under Section 139 NI Act and on exhibits showing liability of Rs 6,69,68,031 as of 31.03.2010.
  • Petitioners’ arguments: (i) Settlement was bilateral and extinguished liability; (ii) Balance sheets did not list petitioner as a sundry debtor, rebutting presumption; (iii) Payments made (cheques 17362, 17363; RTGS amounts) settled the debt; (iv) Cited Gimpex (P) Ltd. vs Manoj Goel (2022) SCC 705 supporting that a compromise subsumes the original complaint.
  • Opposite party’s arguments: (i) Revisional jurisdiction limited; (ii) Settlement did not discharge the original liability; (iii) Payments cited by petitioners relate to different transactions; (iv) Presumption under Section 139 remains unrebutted; (v) No jurisdictional error in lower courts.
  • Legal precedents cited: Lalita Kumar Sharma vs State of U.P. (2008) SCC 638; Southern Sales & Services vs Sauermilch Design (2008) SCC 457; Kumar Export vs Sharma Carpets (2009) SCC 513; Gimpex (P) Ltd. vs Manoj Goel (2022) SCC 705; Charan Singh vs State of U.P. (2004) SCC 205; Sangabij Tari vs Kishore S. Borcer (2025) SCC 2069.
  • Court’s reasoning: Reiterated that revisional courts cannot overturn concurrent factual findings of trial and appellate courts absent perversity. Found that the settlement did not nullify the original cheques, that the presumption under Section 139 was not rebutted, and that the petitioners failed to discharge the burden of proof. Noted that the balance‑sheet omissions do not, by themselves, extinguish the debt.

Final Outcome

  • The High Court dismissed CRR 3762 of 2023 and, by analogy, CRR 3970 of 2023. The convictions and sentences under the NI Act remain in force. No relief granted to petitioners.

Topics: Negotiable Instruments, Criminal Procedure