Authority: High Court of Judicature at Bombay, Circuit Bench at Kolhapur (Civil Appellate Jurisdiction)

Order Date: 16 November 2026

Case Overview

  • Petitioners: Multiple former directors/chairmen of Solapur District Central Co‑operative Bank Ltd., including Sanjay Vitthalrao Shinde (W.P. 5976/2026), Ranjitsinh Vijaysinh Mohite‑Patil (W.P. 5971/2026, 5972/2026, 5975/2026), Dilip Brahmadev Mane (W.P. 5973/2026), Suresh Siddappa Hassapure (W.P. 5974/2026, 5977/2026), Jaywantrao Namdevrao Jagtap (W.P. 5978/2026), Baban Baburao Autade (W.P. 5979/2026) and numerous co‑petitioners (total 172 respondents listed).
  • Respondents: 1. Divisional Joint Registrar, Co‑operative Societies, Pune Division; 2. Returning Officer, Election to the Board of Directors of the Bank; 3. Solapur District Central Co‑operative Bank Ltd. (through its CEO); 4‑7. State Co‑operative Election Authority, State of Maharashtra (Principal Secretary, Co‑operation, Marketing & Textile Dept.) and other co‑respondents.
  • Background: The petitioners had been members/directors of the Bank from 2009 to 2018. An enquiry under Section 88 of the Maharashtra Co‑operative Societies Act (MCS Act) found them “responsible” for conduct detrimental to depositors. The Commissioner, on 28 May 2018, superseded the Board and appointed an Administrator under Section 110‑A(1)(iii) of the MCS Act.
  • The Returning Officer, on 3 November 2026, rejected the petitioners’ nomination forms for the 2026‑2027 Board election, invoking disqualification under Section 73CA(1)(f)(iii) (responsibility under Section 88) and Section 73CA(3A) (supersession order).
  • The petitioners appealed to the Divisional Joint Registrar, which on 6 November 2026 confirmed the rejection. The petitioners then filed the above writ petitions seeking relief, arguing that they had resigned on 15 May 2018 (before the enquiry concluded) and that the appellate authority had failed to stay the supersession order within the time‑frame prescribed in W.P. 2347/2025.
  • Counsel for petitioners (Senior Counsel Girish Godbole, Advocate Abhijit Kulkarni) relied on Supreme Court judgments (Prakash Mahadeo Khot v Maruti Dadu Khot; Dilip Abhaykumar Phade v Deputy Registrar; Mool Chand Yadav v Raza Buland Sugar Co.; Kalabharati Advertising v Hemant Vimalnath Narichania) asserting that pending appeals should stay the operative effect of disqualification orders.
  • Respondent No. 3 (the Bank) argued that the disqualification was squarely within the statutory provisions and that the petitioners remained board members throughout the enquiry; therefore the disqualification was valid.
  • The State’s AGP (Ms. Tejas J. Kapre) contended that the order of 28 May 2018 revealed a ₹238 crore scam, justifying the Board’s supersession and the petitioners’ disqualification.
  • Respondents 4‑6 (various election officials) maintained that the pendency of the appeal does not remove the statutory bar and that an election petition under Section 77A MCS Act is the appropriate remedy.

Final Outcome

  • Justice Abhay J. Mani held that the petitioners were members of the Board at the time the enquiry under Section 88 was initiated (3 February 2018) and remained so until their resignations in 2018; the resignation was not accepted before the enquiry commenced.
  • The Court observed that the appellate authority had neither granted a stay nor decided the appeal against the supersession order, and therefore the disqualification under Section 73CA(1)(f)(iii) and Section 73CA(3A) remained effective.
  • Consequently, the Court found no illegality or perversity in the orders of the Returning Officer and the Divisional Joint Registrar.
  • All nine writ petitions (W.P. 5971‑5979/2026) were dismissed. No order as to costs was made, and the rule was discharged.

Topics: Co‑operative Bank Election, Director Disqualification