Authority: Calcutta High Court (Constitutional Writ Jurisdiction)
Order Date: 20 November 2026
Case Overview
- Petitioner: Prasanta Biswas, former Customer Assistant of State Bank of India (SBI), filing WPA 11856 of 2016 against SBI and others.
- Respondents: State Bank of India and its officials (including Branch Manager, Regional Manager, Disciplinary Authority, Appellate Authority).
- Hearing Date: 28 September 2026 before Hon'ble Justice Partha Sarathi Chatterjee.
- Background: While posted at SBI’s Bally Durgapur Branch, the petitioner was alleged to have committed six acts of misconduct between 2 September 2013 and 23 April 2014, involving double debits, unauthorised withdrawals, failure to verify signatures, and delayed credit of customer deposits. Amounts involved included Rs.1,000, Rs.7,000, Rs.6,000, Rs.60,000 and Rs.6,750.
- Disciplinary Timeline:
- 2 Sep 2013 – Double debit of Rs.1,000 on a customer account; petitioner claimed to have refunded the excess on 13 Sep 2013 and obtained customer acknowledgment on 14 Jan 2014.
- 16 Sep 2013 & 6 Dec 2013 – Branch Manager (Respondent No.7) issued show‑cause notices; petitioner asserted verbal explanations.
- 7 Jan 2015 – Petitioner's suspension under Clause 12(B) of the Memorandum of Settlement (MoS).
- 23 Apr 2015 – Charge‑sheet served with six articles of charge, invoking Clause 7(c) of MoS (minor misconduct) but describing the acts as “major misconduct”.
- 28 May 2015 – Departmental enquiry instituted; 26 Jun 2015 – three charges modified.
- 19 Aug 2015 – Enquiry Officer’s report found five of six charges proved (Charge 3 dismissed).
- 5 Dec 2015 – Disciplinary Authority imposed penalty of removal from service without disqualification, treating suspension period as “Not on Duty”.
- 17 Mar 2016 – Appellate Authority affirmed the penalty.
- 18 Jan 2016 – Petitioner filed statutory appeal (dismissed on 17 Mar 2016).
- Petitioner’s Contentions: Procedural irregularities (absence of detailed charge‑sheet, lack of document/witness lists, delayed provision of documents), mis‑classification of misconduct (minor vs major), violation of natural‑justice principles, no financial loss to the bank, and disproportionate penalty.
- Respondents’ Contentions: Petitioner admitted irregularities, refunded amounts, acted wilfully, and the disciplinary process complied with the MoS; the erroneous reference to Clause 7(c) was an inadvertent clerical error and did not vitiate the proceedings.
- Court’s Analysis:
- Judicial review in disciplinary matters is limited to the decision‑making process, not the merits, unless the decision is perverse, irrational or grossly disproportionate.
- The petitioner failed to demonstrate prejudice from the alleged procedural lapses; he was supplied with document and witness lists and given inspection opportunities on 14 May and 14 July 2015.
- The erroneous citation of Clause 7(c) instead of Clause 5(j) was deemed a harmless mistake; the charge‑sheet clearly described the acts as major misconduct.
- No material prejudice was shown from the change of the Disciplinary Authority.
- The Court found the enquiry officer’s findings supported by evidence for five charges; the cumulative nature of the misconduct (unauthorised handling of customer funds) justified the severity of the penalty.
- Refund of amounts and absence of financial loss do not absolve the employee of misconduct.
Final Outcome
- The writ petition is dismissed as devoid of merit; the removal from service stands.
- No order as to costs.
Topics: Judicial Review of Bank Disciplinary Proceedings; Employee Misconduct in Banking