Authority: Supreme Court of India, Civil Appellate Jurisdiction
Order Date: 16 November 2026
Case Overview
- Parties: Appellant – M/s. Sterling and Wilson Pvt. Ltd.; Respondents – Union of India and others.
- Procedural History: The appellant challenged, via Writ Petition No. 4616 of 2025 before the Bombay High Court, the order dated 17 January 2025 of the Joint Commissioner, CGST & CX, Thane, and the Summary Order dated 24 January 2025 of the Superintendent of Central Tax, Range V, Santa Cruz, which demanded CGST, SGST and penalties totalling ₹53,35,80,964. The High Court dismissed the writ on the ground of an available alternate remedy. The Supreme Court stayed the 17 January 2025 order on 25 August 2025 and, after hearing counsel, decided to hear the matter on merits.
- Taxation Issue: The dispute centred on the GST liability for supply and installation of Solar Power Generating (SPG) systems under EPC contracts for the period 01 July 2017 to 31 December 2018. The revenue authorities treated the supply as a works contract (immovable property) and applied a 70 % goods / 30 % services valuation with CGST/SGST at 5 % on goods and 18 % on services, arguing that the 70:30 ratio introduced by Notification No. 24/2018‑C.T. (effective 01 January 2019) should apply retrospectively.
- Statutory Framework: Section 9(1) CGST Act, Notification 1/2017‑C.T. (Schedule I, Serial 234) listed SPG systems under a 2.5 % CGST rate (implying 5 % total GST). Subsequent GST Council meetings (14th, 15th, 31st, 45th) led to Notification 24/2018‑C.T. (effective 01 January 2019) inserting an Explanation that the value of goods in such composite supplies be deemed 70 % of the total consideration, with the remaining 30 % treated as service value. Circular No. 163/19/2021‑GST clarified that assessees could optionally apply the 70:30 split for the period 01 July 2017‑31 December 2018, but it was not mandatory and no refunds would be granted for over‑payment.
- Judicial Reasoning: The Court examined the definition of works contract (Sec 2(119) CGST Act) and composite supply (Sec 2(30) CGST Act) and noted that a works contract requires the end product to be immovable property. Relying on precedents (TTG Industries Ltd. v. Collector of Central Excise, Sirpur Paper Mills and Bharti Airtel cases), the Court held that attachment of SPG systems to a civil foundation does not render them immovable; they can be detached and relocated without damage, indicating movability. Consequently, the supply is a composite supply of goods, not a works contract, and the 70:30 split cannot be imposed retrospectively.
- Penalty and Limitation: The revenue authorities invoked Section 122(2)(b) CGST Act for penalty and invoked the extended limitation under Section 74. The Court found no evidence of wilful misstatement or fraud; the appellant had merely followed the tax regime applicable at the time (5 % GST on the whole contract). Hence, penalties and the extended limitation were unsustainable.
- Other Developments: The Court noted subsequent amendments – Notification 8/2021‑C.T. (30 September 2021) replacing Serial 234 with Serial 201A, removing the word “system” and reaffirming the 70:30 split for post‑2019 periods only.
Final Outcome
- The appeal is allowed. The order dated 17 January 2025 of the Joint Commissioner, CGST & CX, Thane, and the consequential Summary Order dated 24 January 2025 of the Superintendent, Central Tax, Range V, Santa Cruz, are set aside.
- Both parties bear their own costs.
Topics: GST Classification, Solar EPC Contracts, Tax Liability