Authority: Supreme Court of India (Civil Appellate Jurisdiction)
Order Date: 18 November 2026
Case Overview
- Parties: Appellant Ashok Kumar (former employee of Central Bank of India) vs Respondents Central Bank of India & others.
- Background: Kumar joined the Bank on 1 March 1969; suspended on 22 November 1978 for alleged defalcation; FIR filed 24 November 1978 under IPC §§ 409, 420, 465, 468, 471, 120B; acquitted on 15 July 1983; State and Bank appeals dismissed 27 May 1991, making acquittal final.
- Disciplinary Proceedings: Charge‑sheet drawn up 16 May 1990; Kumar filed writ petition on 11 June 1991 challenging the disciplinary action, arguing criminal acquittal precluded it.
- High Court Relief: On 12 Oct 2007 the Punjab & Haryana High Court allowed the writ, quashing the enquiry, ordering reinstatement (if not superannuated) and consequential benefits.
- Subsequent Appeals: Intra‑court appeal by the Bank dismissed 20 Dec 2007; Special Leave Petition by the Bank dismissed by this Court on 26 July 2011.
- Retirement & Payments: Kumar retired on 31 Mar 2009 while under suspension. The Bank paid Rs 37,07,445.61 on 1 Dec 2011 and Rs 4,89,198 towards PF, total > Rs 42,00,000, confirmed by High Court on 28 Oct 2013.
- Interest Claim: Kumar filed a fresh writ petition on 26 May 2015 seeking interest at 18 % p.a. compounded on delayed salary and 24 % on accrued interest. The High Court dismissed on 11 Dec 2023, holding that interest was not claimed in the original writ and could not be added now.
- Miscellaneous Application: On 26 Feb 2024 Kumar filed a CPC‑Sec‑151 miscellaneous application in the earlier writ petition, again seeking the same interest. The Single Judge dismissed it on 21 Mar 2024; the Division Bench upheld the dismissal on 9 May 2024.
- Legal Reasoning: The Court emphasized that a miscellaneous application is limited to ancillary matters (clerical errors, clarification, extension of time, etc.) and cannot be used to raise a fresh substantive claim such as interest. It invoked constructive res judicata, Order II Rule 2 CPC, and the principle that a claim not raised earlier is barred.
Final Outcome
- The Division Bench affirmed the dismissal of Kumar’s miscellaneous application and the Single Judge’s order.
- Exercising power under Article 142 of the Constitution, the Court directed Central Bank of India to pay an additional sum of Rs 5,00,000 to Kumar as full and final settlement of his dues.
- The additional amount must be paid within two months of the production of a copy of this judgment before the Bank’s competent authority.
- All connected applications, if any, stand disposed of.
Topics: Judicial Relief, Banking Employment Dispute, Interest Claim